the DON JONES INDEX… |
|
|||
|
GAINS
POSTED in GREEN LOSSES
POSTED in RED |
|
||
|
8/6/21… 14,296.17
7/30/21… 14,281.79 6/27/13… 15,000.00 |
|||
(THE
DOW JONES INDEX: 8/6/21…35,064.25; 7/30/21…35,084.53; 6/27/13… 15,000.00) |
||||
LESSON for August 6, 2021 – HIT the ROAD, JACK!
Before Covid-19,
evictions were a hot topic, declaimed a May issue of the Economist UK as cited
the American publication of “Evicted”, a “rare wonk-bestseller by Matthew
Desmond of Princeton University” which followed eight families turfed out of
their homes in Milwaukee, their possessions unceremoniously dumped on the
pavement. (Mr Desmond estimated that there were a million evictions a year in
pre-plague America, a staggering number given the relatively small number of
people affected - about 2.3m adults and children). Then, when covid-19 hit, an
“experiment” took place. The Trump administration issued an edict pausing
evictions, a policy continued by the Biden White House until, on May 5th a
judge struck down the federal moratorium, apparently ending the experiment.
What were the results?
The federal moratorium actually consisted of
several policies spanning the Trump and Biden administrations. From March to
August 2020 it was part of the Cares Act (See
particulars here).
From September it took the form of a directive from the Centres
for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), which was extended
three times to end on June 30th this year. The CDC claimed
authority on the ground that evicting people in the middle of an epidemic was a
public-health risk. That seems to be true. From May to September 2020, 27
states lifted their eviction moratoriums. Comparing the trend before the
pandemic to the trend in infection and deaths once the moratoriums were lifted,
researchers estimate that states without moratoriums experienced covid-19
infection rates twice as high as states with them.
These same states were most likely not to have issued
eviction moratoriums on their own, letting free enterprise have its say and the
landlords have their day.
Fox News reports that only ten states had taken up the
burden of eviction relief… all of them with higher vaccination and lower plague
rates, all of them blue. (See Attachment
One for list)
HOW DID we get to this point?
When it became apparent that many of the Covid
jobs lost were not coming back… for a long time, if at all… President Trump and
Congress declared a temporary moratorium on evictions, which was extended by
the Biden administration to July 31st.
After the CDC could
not find legal grounds to extend a moratorium on evictions that began early in
the coronavirus pandemic, Rep. Maxine
Waters, D-Calif., began
pushing the CDC to do it anyway, according to Fox News.
President Biden announced Thursday that he was not going
to try to extend the moratorium, calling on Congress to take action instead. Waters,
who unsuccessfully tried to pass a bill, expressed skepticism that the CDC
could not extend the moratorium as they had done in the past.
"I don't buy that
the CDC can't extend the eviction moratorium - something it has already done in
the past!" Waters tweeted. "Who is going to stop them? Who is going
to penalize them? There is no official ruling saying that they cannot extend
this moratorium. C'mon CDC - have a heart! Just do it!"
Despite what Waters
posted, there was an official ruling on this in May from U.S. District Judge
Dabney Friedrich, who said the CDC acted outside the scope of its authority
when it previously issued the moratorium.
(See Attachment Two) That order
was put on hold pending an appeal of the decision, and while the Supreme Court
denied a request to vacate the stay on the ruling, it was only because it was
already set to expire on July 31.
President Biden and
the White House as of Monday morning didn't respond to a statement
from House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and her leadership team calling on
the executive branch to extend the federal eviction moratorium,
as "Squad" Democrats continued to camp on the Capitol steps
in protest of the inaction from their party. (Fox News)
"Action is needed, and it must come from
the Administration. That is why House leadership is calling on the
Administration to immediately extend the moratorium," Pelosi, D-Calif.,
and her leadership team said in a Sunday morning statement hours after the
moratorium ended.
“I wish that the president, (and) the C.D.C. would have gone
forward and extended the moratorium,” Waters,
chairwoman of the House Financial Services Committee, said in an interview with The New
York Times on Monday. “They have the power to do
that. I think he should have gone in and he should have done it, and let the
chips fall where they may.”
Ms. Waters echoed that sentiment in a letter to colleagues on
Tuesday, assailing the Biden administration for its “refusal” to extend the
moratorium and for a “last-minute punt to Congress.”
BEER,
HERE!
The Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention (CDC), early in the coronavirus pandemic,
had implemented an eviction moratorium that banned landlords from removing
people who were behind on their rent – which provision was extended multiple
times but finally ended Saturday night following a June opinion from Supreme
Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh that “clear and specific
congressional authorization (via new legislation)” would be required. (See
Attachment Three)
Fox News (Attachment Four) said that Progressive Democrats
in the House of Representatives were “livid” at their party leadership for
allegedly not taking the eviction moratorium seriously. Sunday night marked
their third night protesting lack of action by Biden and Democrats in Congress
by camping out on the steps of the Capitol.
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez,
D-N.Y., says Democratic leadership could have extended the moratorium if
it had the will to.
"Everybody knew this was
coming," she said Friday at the protest. "We were sounding the alarm
about this issue. The court order was not yesterday, the court order was not
Monday, the court order was about a month ago."
Congress recoiled from this hot, rotten potato dumped back
in its lap. Even big-city liberals
paused and raised fingers to the wind… a lot of their re-election and
off-the-books-perks derive from the real estate lobby. Open Secrets
has noted that realtors raised $15,501,505 for PAC years 2019-2020 – shelling
out 52.14% to Democrats, 47.79% to
Republicans.
PAC Summary
Data, 2019-2020
Total Raised $15,501,505
Total Spent $12,607,348
Begin Cash
on Hand $8,205,291
End Cash on
Hand Receipts $11,099,448
Debts $0
Independent
Expenditures $2,992,290
Date of Last
Report December 31, 2020
PAC
Contribution Data, 2019-2020
Contributions
from this PAC to federal candidates (list recipients)
52.14% to Democrats, 47.79% to Republicans $3,960,998
So they did what losers always do when faced with an
overwhelmingly bad/worse choice… as Rep. Waters alleged: they punted.
The Supreme Court had upheld the CDC's moratorium,
reversing a ruling from a federal appeals court June 29, but warned that a
further extension of the ban beyond its July 31 deadline would exceed the
agency's authority unless Congress passed a law to expand it. The House did
not attempt to do so until Friday, two days before the ban lapsed and one day
after Biden asked Congress to extend the CDC moratorium.
White House officials told The Hill on Monday that the
agency was unable to justify even a narrowed extension of the ban to hard-hit
areas given the court's decision.
"To date, the CDC director and her team have been
unable to find legal authority, even for a more targeted eviction moratorium
that would focus just on counties with higher rates of COVID spread," said
Gene Sperling, Biden's economic recovery czar.
Homelessness, men and women of medicine mostly agree, is not
conducive to good health. People freeze
to death in winter, die of heatstroke in summer and are frequently targeted for
beatings, or worse, by the police, by cruel teenagers and POTheads
(followers of the Party of Trump who direct their anger downwards) out for
kicks or, lets face it, each other.
Heightened rates of communicable disease, Covid or other, as well as suicide are endemic.
“What the pandemic is doing is it is
upending all the structures and supports that we have in place to handle
emotional unrest in a small number of people. Now we have a whole lot of people
that are experiencing increased anxiety and depression all at once,” said
Jonathan Singer in an interview with Courier. Singer is president of the
American Association of Suicidology and associate professor of social work at
Loyola University in Chicago. In
separate interview with The Guardian UK, Singer also said the there could be a
“dramatic increase in suicide deaths, or at least despair.”
Housing (or its absence) can also play
a part in suicide. According to the National Health Care For The Homeless
Council, a 2012 study found
that suicide rates were 10 times higher for people experiencing homelessness
than the general population.
The United States was already
struggling with an affordable housing crisis before the pandemic hit. The Eviction Lab at Princeton University
found, in 2016 there were well over 2 million eviction filings in the United
States. Today, as millions of people are out of work and have no reliable
source of income, rent is often taking a backseat to necessities like groceries
and medicine. Without moratoriums on evictions, hundreds of thousands of
families are in a precarious situation.
“Losing your home takes away an
important protective factor and may lead to family splits. It increases suicide
risk, no question about it,” said Steve Moore in another interview with The Guardian. Moore
serves as the co-chair of the Illinois chapter of the American Foundation for
Suicide Prevention.
Nor has help from the forty refusenik states been
forthcoming.
In Georgia, for example, the Atlanta Journal-Constitution
reported that renters who relied on the stop-gap pandemic measure were holding
their breaths, too.
In DeKalb County, outside of Atlanta, 145 writs of eviction
were already scheduled to be executed when Superior Court Judge Asha Jackson
signed an emergency order Friday that created a local ban on evictions for
another 60 days. Roughly 1,650 more are pending with the marshal’s office
there. DeKalb officials blamed a cyberattack earlier this year for dramatically
slowing distribution of federal rental
assistance.
Other localities have not been so fortunate in finding
excuses. Evictions are already queued up
in Fulton, Gwinnett, Cobb and Clayton and other counties. Though many counties
didn’t carry out tenant removals during the moratoriums, a lot of landlords and
property managers already have court orders in hand that allow them to kick out
some of those who are delinquent on rent. They are just waiting for law
enforcement officers to carry out the orders.
Others have filed the legal paperwork required to evict
tenants but are waiting for their day in court. Before hearings are scheduled,
tenants have a week to respond. If they do, trial dates are set. But if they
don’t — or if they lose at trial — they have a week to move out.
“These things scare me,” said Protip
Biswas, vice president for homelessness at the United Way of Greater Atlanta,
which has disbursed millions of dollars in rental assistance. “We really don’t
know the scale of the emergency.”
An eviction can dog a tenant for years, crimping future
choices, said Elora Raymond, an assistant professor
at Georgia Tech who studies housing issues.
It can also have broader consequences for mental health,
performance in school and birth weights, said Emily Lemmerman,
a research specialist at the Eviction Lab.
Kathy Poland-Jones, 65, has a past eviction on her record,
but managed to find a place in Canton. She lost her full-time job and took
part-time work. But she hasn’t been able to keep up her payments. She got an
eviction notice in June. “Nobody would rent to me before,” she said. “I have no
idea where to go.”
Around the country, courts, legal advocates and law
enforcement agencies are gearing up for evictions to return to pre-pandemic
levels, a time when 3.7 million people were already being displaced from their
homes every year… seven every minute, according to the Eviction Lab, as
reported by the Associated Press (See Attachment Five), citing backlogs in St.
Louis, Minneapolis and Milwaukee.
Landlords tired of waiting for federal rental assistance
were in court hoping to evict their tenants, while families from Ohio to Virginia
turned up before judges hoping for a last-minute reprieve. In Detroit, at least
600 tenants with court orders against them were at immediate risk.
“It’s very scary with the moratorium being over,” said Ted
Phillips, a lawyer who leads the United Community Housing Coalition in Detroit.
"The thing I worry about the
most is that you have millions of people across the country who may get evicted
over the next couple of months, even though there is enough money coming from
the federal government to pay all their back rent," Shamus Roller, who
heads up the National Housing Law Project, told NPR.
No one knows for sure what the weeks ahead will bring. The
coming evictions could be “a light sprinkle or a typhoon,” said Jim Lindenmayer, director of the Cherokee County Homeless
Veteran Program.
The available numbers hinted that the weeks ahead would
bring potential disaster: More than one of every five renters in Georgia is
behind on rent payments, according to a survey by the Census Bureau. But how
bad it will be comes down to a long list of variables — how fast courts will
sift through backlogs of eviction filings, how many landlords are willing to
negotiate, how efficient counties are at disbursing rental assistance, and
how many members of Congress are willing to act on President Joe Biden’s call
to reinstitute the temporary moratorium.
Those questions make it hard to prepare, Lindenmayer
said.
Nearly 25% of renters are in arrears in Georgia, compared
with just 6% in Idaho, the Center
on Budget and Policy Priorities has found.
The six counties with the highest of renters behind are all in
South Carolina, and include Allendale, Bamberg, Barnwell, Colleton, Hampton and
Orangeburg, according to an analysis by Surgo
Ventures, a nonprofit. As many as 1 in 3 renters may be behind in these places.
And generally, hardship rates are worse in the South.
There are a number of reasons for that, said Aaron Dibner-Dunlap, senior research scientist at Surgo
Ventures.
“Before the pandemic, southern states also had relatively
high eviction rates,” Dibner-Dunlap said. “So housing
vulnerability has been a challenge in this region for a number of years.”
Another factor? “Most states in the South haven’t
adopted Medicaid
expansion, so you also see huge s of the population
without adequate health care if they get sick,” he said. “Research consistently
shows that large shocks in one area — like a huge medical expense — can send
people into a financial tailspin.”
Meanwhile, in deep blue Northern states like Connecticut,
landlords can’t move forward with an eviction unless they’ve applied for
federal rental assistance. And if they file an eviction before October, they
need to provide tenants with 30 days’ notice.
The rules can get complicated fast, and sometimes landlords
ignore them.
As the plague worsened and spread internationally, some of
the wealthier, more urbanized nations which had already been experiencing
landlord-tenant strife for years had attempted turning to rent controls; increasingly popular, especially, in many European
nations. Rent controls, CNBC explains (Attachment Six) are government policies, whether on local or a national level, that aim
to cap house price increases and are becoming increasingly popular in many European
nations, They are intended to keep housing affordable, at least for the most
vulnerable parts of a population, but experts noted by the landlord lobby
contend that they rarely solve housing crises on their own and can even scare
investors away.
In Sweden, for example, rent controls effectively toppled the
government there. The nationalist Sweden
Democrats had seized the chance to call the vote after the formerly communist
Left Party withdrew support for the centre-left government over a plan to ease
rent controls for new-build apartments; a no-confidence motion, which required
175 votes in the 349-seat parliament to pass, was supported by 181 lawmakers.
(Reuters, 6/21/21)
Prime Minister Stefan Lofven’s
“shaky” minority coalition with the Green Party had relied on support in
parliament from two small centre-right parties and the Left Party since a tight
election in the European Union member state in 2018, according to Reuters.
The Left Party blamed Lofven for
triggering the crisis.
“It is not the Left Party that has given up on the Social
Democrat government, it is the Social Democrat government that has given up on the
Left Party and the Swedish people,” Left Party leader Nooshi
Dadgostar said.
With parliament deadlocked, it is not clear to whom the
speaker might turn to form a new government if Lofven
resigns. Opinion polls suggest the centre-left and centre-right blocs are
evenly balanced, so a snap election might not bring clarity either.
Meanwhile, lawmakers in the Netherlands,
Germany, the U.K. and Ireland have all had similar discussions about their
property markets as also, driven by the pandemic (if not the Olympics), Japan.
Speaking about lofty prices in the Netherlands,
Nic Vrieselaar, a senior economist at RaboResearch, told CNBC that the market is “becoming
unacceptable.” “This is a matter of supply-demand due to the low interest rate
environment,” he said.
Between 2010 and the first quarter of 2021, rents increased
by 15.3% in
the European Union, according to Eurostat.
Separate data gathered
by Europe’s statistics office showed that, in 2020, the estimated average rent
levels for apartments was the highest in Dublin, followed by Copenhagen, then
Paris, Luxembourg and Stockholm.
Colm Lauder,
head of real estate at investment bank Goodbody, told CNBC that he expects
rental prices to keep rising. He said: “In Ireland, we are concerned that
[rent] controls will stop capital coming through.”
A vicious cycle
Property investors see a significant downside in rent
controls in that they cap returns. In the case of Ireland, rent increases in
certain areas are limited at 4% per year.
“If they can’t get [returns] then they will look elsewhere,”
Lauder said.
CNBC cites an age-old trend of people flocking
to urban areas where there’s more jobs and higher salaries. But, at a time of
low interest rates from central banks — which European nations have experienced
in the wake of the sovereign debt crisis — and help-to-buy schemes, more people
have bought property, either as a first home or as an investment to let. This
demand, according to CNBC, then pushes up prices given the limited housing
stock on the market.
There is another, simpler explanation… greed.
“Rent seeking” (see below) has long been the
bane of “civilized” (i.e. the Westernized, white… plus Japan, maybe Taiwan and
Korea… nations) society. After all, it’s
hard to go to work every day, deal with your own personal Bezos, fall asleep,
struggle up and do it all over and over again for a lifetime than it is to sit
back, sip a cool cocktail and rake in the fruits of other people’s labor all
for yourself. That is, unless the system
corrodes, buckles and (with a little help from the plague) collapses entirely.
Rent
Seeking: noun
the fact or practice of manipulating public
policy or economic conditions as a strategy for increasing profits.
"cronyism and rent-seeking have become an
integral part of the way our biggest companies do business"
adjective
engaging in or involving the manipulation of
public policy or economic conditions as a strategy for increasing profits.
"rent-seeking lobbyists"
Definitions
from Oxford Languages
In Germany, the issue of rents outpacing wages was
subject to a year-long legal battle. Barbara
Steenbergen, a member of the International Union of
Tenants and former lawmaker for the German region of Cologne, told CNBC: “We
are of course pro rent controls if it’s part of a comprehensive housing package.”
She highlighted how important rent
controls are for low and middle-income families, noting that in Berlin, for
example, rent increases have gone up exponentially, but salaries have not.
This divide is a “threat to social peace,” she
said.
Still, Lauder, head of real estate at investment bank
Goodbody, told CNBC that he expects rental prices to keep rising. He said: “In
Ireland, we are concerned that [rent] controls will stop capital coming
through.”
For the rent-seekers, the trains always arrive on time.
Does a win-win solution exist? Of course it does. Most landlords and many renters advocate
direct government subsidies minus new construction and management – just cash
payments to the tenants. Cold hard cash,
paid for… or not… by the usual suspects, by the usual means…
In effect, taxing the working and middle classes to
subsidize the poor to pay market rents to the rich.
What could go wrong with that?
Due to widespread job loss and the health risks of the
Covid-19 pandemic, Vox explains, many renters in the US faced difficulty making
their rent payments every month when the pandemic began in early 2020, and the
federal government stepped in to prevent people from
getting evicted in the midst of it. As part of this response, the Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention instituted a moratorium in September 2020 that
prevented landlords from evicting their tenants regardless of whether they
could pay their monthly rent in full or at all.
By last month the moratorium was already on borrowed time,
as the Supreme Court had warned that it would not extend the renter
protection past the end of July. Five justices including Justice Brett
Kavanaugh supported this. “In my view, clear and specific
congressional authorization (via new legislation) would be necessary for the
CDC to extend the moratorium past July 31,” wrote Kavanaugh.
An August second press release by President Joe, delivered
to hungry media teeth and stomachs by Jen Psaki offloaded the blame onto the
locals.
“State and local
governments received Emergency Rental Assistance—a $46.5 billion plan to
protect millions of Americans facing deep rental debt and potential eviction
during the pandemic – via the American Rescue Plan that Congress and the Biden
Administration enacted in March 2021. Some cities and States have demonstrated
their ability to release these funds efficiently to tenants and landlords in
need. But even though funds began to be distributed in February by the Biden
Administration, too many States and cities have been too slow to act,” Jen and
Joe pointed fingers towards the Capitol.
“States and cities have
been slow to distribute the $45 billion in
federal rental assistance allocated by Congress,” broadcast Annie Nova of CNBC.
“Those funds were authorized in the last two major coronavirus stimulus packages, passed in December and March, and
yet just $3 billion has
reached households, according to data by the U.S. Treasury.”
"The American Rescue Plan
allocated an additional $21.5 billion for Emergency Rental Assistance (ERA)
that can be used by renters to cover arrears and make landlords whole. This is
on top of $25 billion allocated under the Consolidated Appropriations
Act," a White House press release referred to by Fox said last month.
"But state and local governments must do better. Money is available in
every state to help renters who are behind on rent and at risk of eviction."
None of that money, for example, trickled down to a homeless
man named Melvin Douglas who, on a sweltering July afternoon biked up to his
sleeping spot beneath the High Line, the elevated, art-filled New York park overlooking
the Hudson River, and found that a city cleanup crew had thrown away his
possessions — again. The same thing had happened the day before. (New York Times, 8/2/21 Attachment Seven)
One homeless book vendor, Michael Jones, told a Timestravelling correspondent that “the city crews had
served a purpose.”
“You had people building shanty towns near the scaffolding
and terrorizing people,” he said. “At the end of the day, people were messing
up a good hustle.”
Help was supposed to be on the way.
Congress set aside nearly $50 billion to help families like hers pay the back
rent they owe and avoid eviction. But that money flowed to states and counties,
which created hundreds of different programs to distribute it. And many so far have
managed to get just a small fraction of the money to the people who need it.
In the matter of Safiya Kitwana of suburban Atlanta, she applied for the help and
she was approved. (NPR 8/2/21)
But DeKalb County officials worried
they might run out of that federal money because so many people needed help. So
to try to spread the money around, they made a rule — the county would pay
landlords only 60% of what renters owed. And to get that, landlords had to
agree to forgive the remainder of the debt or split the difference with the
renter and drop the eviction case.
But, as NPR previously reported,
some landlords like Kitwana's said that wasn't enough
money and moved ahead with the eviction process. There is also a provision of the law
requiring Renters to pay any missed payments, and in some states
the landlord is owed late fees for any late payment since the moratorium was
enacted. Utilities are a bit of a gray area, Vox reported, “but generally if
the landlord is responsible for paying for a certain utility, in most
cases they are not permitted to turn it off.”
The false promises have been ubiquitous, resulting in real
consequences.
The Biden administration had hoped that historic amounts of
rental assistance allocated by Congress would help avert a crisis. But the
distribution has been painfully slow: Only about $3 billion of the first
tranche of $25 billion had been distributed through June by states and
localities. A second amount of $21.5 billion would go to the states. Renters would eventually have to start paying
again whether their individual circumstances had changed or not.
In an attempt to remedy this, Congress allocated $25 billion in rental
assistance in December, and in March, another $21.5 billion was added. This was
a welcome relief to tenants and landlords alike, but the problem was in getting
the money to the people who needed it, quickly. Confusion at the federal level
about how to distribute that amount of money, and which of numerous programs
would handle distribution, has also slowed getting the aid out. As Vox’s
Jerusalem Demsas has reported, “many renters in need
of aid simply did not know that they were eligible for rent relief, and if they
did, some were unable to provide the necessary paperwork because
of their turbulent living circumstances, lack of formal documentation of their
work, or nontraditional rental agreements.” (See Attachment Eight)
While more than $1.5 billion was delivered to
eligible applicants in the month of June, which exceeded the amount provided in
all three previous reporting periods combined, only $3 billion of the total $45 billion
allocated has been distributed, according to the US Treasury. Now that the
federal moratorium has expired, at least four states — Massachusetts, Nevada,
New York, and Oregon — have temporarily continued the ban on evictions against
those with a pending rental assistance application. These state decisions will
give renters time to receive their rent relief money when they might otherwise
face eviction immediately. But renters in states that are following the expired
federal moratorium face large sums of back rent, and if they are unable to pay,
possible eviction.
More than 15 million people live in households that owe as
much as $20 billion to their landlords, according to the Aspen Institute. As of
July 5, roughly 3.6 million people in the U.S. said they faced eviction in the
next two months, according to the U.S. Census Bureau’s Household Pulse
Survey. Parts of the South and other
regions with weaker tenant protections were expected to see the largest spikes
and communities of color where vaccination rates are sometimes lower and job
loss almost universally higher, would be hit hardest.
"In light of the Supreme
Court’s ruling, the President calls on Congress to extend the eviction
moratorium to protect such vulnerable renters and their families without
delay," White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki told Fox News last week.
(Attachment Four, above)
But the votes were not there in either the
House or the Senate, so, said the Fox, “the eviction ban expired.”
On Sunday night, the Associated Press reported, House
Speaker Nancy Pelosi and the House Democratic leaders called on the Biden
administration to immediately extend the moratorium, calling it a “moral imperative”
to prevent Americans from being put out of their homes during a COVID-19 surge.
And then Monday dawned.
“Most expect the wave of evictions to build slowly over the
coming weeks and months,” the AP suggested (rather Pollyannishly
as it turned out), “as the bureaucracy of removing people from their homes
restarts.”
Such was not to be the case.
Hungry landlords trooped to the courts to file papers for
eviction – many had done so in advance with the co-operation of landlord
friendly clerks and judges.
Some of the cities with the most cases, according to the
Eviction Lab, are Phoenix with more than 42,000 eviction filings, Houston with
more than 37,000, Las Vegas with nearly 27,000 and Tampa more than 15,000.
Indiana and Missouri also have more than 80,000 filings.
So, as Monday soldiered on, the evictors worked their magic,
renters shuddered in fear and the White House issued yet another press
statement and economic recovery czar Sperling told The Hill that… while Biden
asked the CDC if it had the power to ban evictions in areas with
particularly high COVID-19 transmission rates… the agency was hemmed in by the
court's decision.
"Even though the eviction moratorium was supposed to
end on the 31st, even though the CDC had said it was their last extension,"
Sperling explained, "there was still a desire, a passion by this president
to go back and say, 'Are we sure? Are we sure?' And he is still asking that
question."
Monday’s AP report lay the race card, the Floyd card, the
poverty and the plague cards on the
table.
The left-wing Truthout reported
numerous instances of police and sheriff brutality as the authorities raced to
catch up on the backlog of evictions, on the model of a pre-moratorium rash of
violent raids upon tenants, including those who, now homeless, found shelter in
abandoned buildings in cities like Oakland.
Dominique Walker, an activist with Moms 4 Housing, “a
collective of unhoused and housing insecure mothers” joined three other working
mothers in reclaiming a vacant,
investor-owned house last November to call attention
to the city’s “displacement machine.”
The Alameda County Sheriff’s Office evicted the moms and their
children in a high-profile, militarized raid in early January. Sherriff’s
deputies decked in riot gear and armed with AR-15s showed up with an armored
tank and a specialized robot. The eviction ultimately cost the county $40,000 —
well beyond the cost of simply housing the families — a point the moms are now
zeroing in on ahead of a looming eviction wave.
Walker told Truthout that
in addition to calling for full rent relief, the moms are targeting the Alameda
County Sheriff’s Office for funding cuts. They want that money reinvested in
organizations that provide housing and a jobs training program focused on
providing mothers with the necessary skills to land jobs that make at least
$40.88 an hour — the minimum wage required to afford a one-bedroom apartment in
Oakland.
“There still hasn’t been an explanation of why they came
with that much force for mothers and babies.”
The January eviction “was a very violent display and was
meant to cause terror in folks who are standing up for their human rights,”
Walker said. “This is the police state that we live in, where they will spend
tens of thousands just to make you get out of a speculative-owned property rather
than help you get permanently housed and fix the issue. It was unreal.”
Walker says the group is still working to plan actions this
week targeting the Alameda County Board of Supervisors budget.
The January eviction “looked like a war scene out of a movie,”
she says. “There still hasn’t been an explanation of why they came with that
much force for mothers and babies, so we still want to hold them accountable
for that while redirecting some of those funds to get mothers and babies off of
the streets.”
Also clocking in were healthcare advocates. “Struggling renters are now facing a health
crisis and an eviction crisis,” said Alicia Mazzara,
a senior research analyst at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.
“Without the CDC’s moratorium, millions of people are at
risk of being evicted or becoming homeless, increasing their exposure to COVID
just as cases are rising across the country. The effects will fall heavily on
people of color, particularly Black and Latino communities, who face greater
risk of eviction and more barriers to vaccination.”
Not all, not even a majority of the
police, sheriffs and other officials charged with the often dangerous job of
enforcing and conducting evictions relish their task.
That was much the way things played out in parts of North
Carolina, where on Monday Sgt. David Ruppe knocked on
a weathered mobile home door in Cleveland County, a rural community an hour
west of Charlotte.
“We haven’t seen much of a difference at all,” he said. “We
would still have evictions issued from the court and we would still serve them
as if it happened pre-COVID.”
He waited a few minutes on the porch scattered with folding
chairs and toys. Then a woman opened the door.
“How are you?” he asked quietly, then explained her landlord
had started the eviction process. The woman told Ruppe
she’d paid, and he said she’d need to bring proof to her upcoming Aug. 9 court
date.
Ruppe, who has two young sons, said seeing families struggle
day-after-day is tough.
“There’s only so much you can do,” he said. “So, if you can
offer them a glimmer of hope, words of encouragement, especially if there’s
kids involved. Being a father, I can relate to that.”
It’s the future.
Shouldn’t there be a robot for this?
Rental property owners usually contend that they want to
negotiate — especially if
there is federal money to
sweeten the pot, attorney Lynn Wilson told the Atlanta Journal-Constitution.
“And there will likely be a lot of encouragement for that from the courts,” she
said.
“We do not foresee, as many have predicted, a tsunami of
evictions,” she said. “These owners have little incentive to evict. Eviction is
always a last resort.”
Still and all, the lawyers are
gathering.
Tenants who find the promise of relief a mirage are turning
to nonprofit and advocacy organizations, where such exist… Americans like Luis Vertentes, told by a judge he had three weeks to clear out
of his one-bedroom apartment in nearby East Providence after being hospitalized
and falling behind on his rent.
“I’m going to be homeless, all because of this pandemic,” Vertentes said. “I feel helpless, like I can’t do anything
even though I work and I got a full-time job.”
He was, however, one of the lucky ones. Outside the courtroom, Katie Barrington, a
case manager with Crossroads Rhode Island, a nonprofit housing and homeless
agency, signed him up with a housing counsellor to help him secure a new home
and enrolled him for federal rental assistance.
While the moratorium was enforced in much of the country,
there were places like Idaho where judges ignored it, said Ali Rabe, executive director
of Jesse Tree, a non-profit that works to prevent evictions in the Boise
metropolitan area.
The non-profit represented renters in about 800 evictions in
the past year, and only once was the moratorium enforced, Rabe said. Statewide
about 1,500 people were evicted in the past year, she said.
“Eviction courts ran as usual,” she said.
Anyone at risk of eviction should seek free
legal help, the experts say. But
sometimes the experts show only their lack of expertise as regards the colder, harder
facts of life.
“There’s a lot of cases where tenants are getting evicted
that have already been approved for rental assistance,” K’Lisha
Rutledge, an attorney with Legal Aid of NorthWest
Texas, told the Texas Tribune. “And their landlord
knows that they’ve been approved, and they’re just waiting on the check.”
And in locations where jobs are plentiful and
rent controls dampen the amount that the rentier class can squeeze out of
tenants, booting long-term renters out and doubling, tripling the loot is a
powerful incentive.
"Action is needed, and it must
come from the Administration. That is why House leadership is calling on the
Administration to immediately extend the moratorium," Pelosi, D-Calif.,
and her leadership team said in a Sunday morning statement hours after the
moratorium ended. Rather than wait for
Biden action, a bunch of the usual suspects… the Squad, Fox News duly reported,
but also newcomers to the perceived politics of protests like Rep. Cori Bush,
D-Mo., who said she'd heard there were "thousands" of evictions on
the first day after the moratorium lifted, with "potentially millions to
come,"… came, sat on the Capitol steps while Pelosi was chairing her riot
investigations, had their pictures taken and then, like the one-six mob,
departed.
As the moratorium question deepened, the legal publisher
NOLO prepared a roster of the individual states, including whether they had
opted into or out of the hold on evictions and, for the benefit of the public,
a list of tenant defense organizations to whom the afflicted (or the merely
curious) might turn. (See this as Attachment
Nine.)
Forty-one percent of
all rental housing units in the US, and most of the affordable housing options,
are owned by individuals, or “mom-and-pop” landlords, and the rent they receive
from their tenants is often a large part of their own income. This means that
the moratorium alleviated pressure from tenants by creating more pressure on
landlords who still need to pay their own bills.
As Vox’s Demsas wrote:
“Losing more of America’s already dwindling affordable
housing stock is a looming emergency that could be exacerbated if small
landlords are required to act as the social welfare state without any financial
assistance.”
The end of the moratorium potentially means money in landlords’ pockets, but there are still
roadblocks. California is allowing landlords to get paid what they are owed
from previous months without rent only if they
waive 20 percent of the back rent. And some landlords have taken such a hit that they will be
forced to sell their property, eliminating the opportunity to continue renting
as a future source of income.
Landlords, even those who had traditionally played by the
rules and watched their darkside competitors grow
darkly rich, found the government’s promises empty. In Rhode Island on Monday, the AP told the
story of Gabe Imondi, a 74-year-old landlord, was in
court hoping to get an eviction execution — the final step to push a tenant out
of one of four housing units he owns in nearby Pawtucket.
Imondi said he and his tenant both filed forms for the billions in
federal aid meant to help keep tenants in their homes but so far, he said, he hasn’t
seen a cent of the state’s $200 million .
A retired general contractor, Imondi
estimates he’s out around $20,000 in lost rent since September, when he began
seeking to evict his tenant for non-payment. The eviction was approved in
January.
“I don’t know what they’re doing with that money,” Imondi said.
“(The eviction moratorium) is now a cautionary tale of how
bad policies distort behavior and are difficult to end,” scowled the Wall
Street Journal (See
Attachment Ten). What else could those
dirty little peasants want?
As opposed to renters’ single-sourcer
websites like NOLO (above), landlords… obviously… have to turn to private
sector relief agencies. Fortunately,
there are plenty of these.
Unfortunately, they charge either a lot or a little, depending on
circumstances, but they will get the job done.
Sometimes it is possible to recoup expenses in subsequent legal or
garnishment action, occasionally there are valuables left behind that can be
sold at a profit.
(A staggering amount of waste ensues when eviction simply
tosses the renter’s property onto the sidewalk where it is subject to the
random ragpicker… at best… or strong rains, at worst. In some locations, the valuables slowly
becoming junk remain on the sidewalk for weeks, obstructing vehicle and
pedestrian traffic and contributing to neighborhood decline… a sensible policy
would be to do as self-storage companies do: move everything to an empty
building or, at least, under a tent, allow a few days or weeks for renters, if
housed elsewhere, to retrieve their belongings and begin the process of
starting over and then sell these goods at the sort of price that would enable
other poor or working families to pick up a desk, for example, or a trashbag of pots and pans or children’s clothes on the cheap. But the concepts of eviction and sense are
mutually incompatible.)
A blurg from a typical eviction
broker, EVICT THEM FOR ME is posted below as Attachment Eleven. (Some of the information therein may also be
useful to renters.)
But the newly evicted, in some places, may find that even
the streets will not accept them.
New York City, as reported the Times a month ago (Attachment
Seven) has on its own accord extended the moratorium to August 31st
but has been cracking down on evictions victims by tossing their belongings
into dumpsters and enforcing the typical “Keep Moving!” policy. The city’s Department of Homeless Services
told the Times it resorts to cleanups only in the case of “service-resistant
individuals” and is committed to helping people find homes.
“The name of the game is compassionate, consistent
outreach,” Bill Neidhardt, a spokesman for the mayor,
said in a statement. “The end goal is always permanent housing.”
But the city’s ability to offer people such housing is limited,
and the process is slow. And advocates for homeless people and some city
employees say the sweeps accomplish little more than chasing people from one
spot to another, upending already precarious lives and — by blurring outreach
and enforcement — discouraging people from accepting help.
“They are trying to make life so miserable on the streets
that people will come into shelters, but that is a cruel and ineffective
approach,” said Josh Dean, the founder of Human.nyc, a policy group focused on
street homelessness. “People need to trust outreach workers, and this approach
is destroying trust.”
Some business leaders interviewed by the Times are
skeptical. “I don’t think persuasion is going to get people off the streets,”
said Barbara Blair, the president of the Garment District Alliance, which
represents businesses and property owners south of Times Square.
Ms. Blair, who has advocated removing homeless people from
Midtown hotels, said the city had “utterly failed in terms of providing
supportive housing for people who are very, very ill.” A middle ground should
be possible, she said.
“The city has to balance keeping the streets livable for the
rest of the population and at the same time removing these people from the
streets into a place that’s safe,” she said.
New York could not remove Melvin Douglas but, the Times
reported, they did snatch his worldly possessions, such as they were. After stashing his belongings neatly behind a
pole under the High Line, he left briefly and returned to find them gone yet
again.
Strike Three.
“I don’t even have a clean change of underwear right now,”
he said as he sat dejectedly beneath a sign announcing that the crew would
return the next day.”
The sun went down on Monday, the moon rose… vultures
gathered in the trees and a lonesome owl hooted “Who? Who?” as the White House signaled they would
continue to try to help find legal authority on the issue, but indicated the
president had no ability to act and somebody else would have to step up.
“On this particular issue, the president has not only kicked
the tires, he has double, triple, quadruple checked,” White House American
Rescue Plan Coordinator Sperling had told the pro-Trump, pro-landlord Breitbart
on Monday.
The administration, again, urged State and local governments
to act on their own to stop renters from getting evicted from their homes.
Everybody, other than the afflicted tenants, enjoyed a good
laugh and raised a stein of suds to Beerman Brett.
As of Tuesday morning, the government, at least, seemed on
the brink (for what seemed the twenty or thirtieth time in two months) of
passing a trillion dollar version of the Infrastructure bill as would pretty up
the High Line, prevent more collapsing bridges, hundred year old sewer leaks
and potholes from developing. The Senate
vows they’re going to stay over for a day or seven to vote on the measure –
there were, at last count, seventeen Republican supporters (seven more than
needed to stave off a suicidal filibuster) on board, but some Democrats are now
saying they will not support a stand-alone bill without the costlier Social
Infrastructure (childcare, healthcare and, of course, housing) grab bag of
three trillion handouts to constituencies ranging from childcare nonprofit
bureaucrats to healthcare bureaucrats to housing bureaucrats.
On the rental and evictions problem… crickets.
The eviction moratorium was “perhaps justifiable amid the
early lockdowns that threw millions out of work,” the Wall Street Journal
grudgingly admitted. The original Cares Act moratorium that only applied to
federally subsidized housing expired last July, but the Trump Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention imposed its version in September. The moratorium
applied to all rental housing and tenants who earned less than $99,000
($198,000 for couples) who claimed they lost income because of the pandemic.
“Landlords who evicted non-paying tenants could go to jail,” the rent-seekers
fired up the terror and, more importantly, waved their wallets.
So, as of Tuesday, three
million renters were being tied to the tracks like debutantes in a silent
movie… side to side they would have lined the railway lines coast-to-coast…
with a humongous train with a spike-studded cowcatcher bearing down. The villains… death, homelessness and a
bipartisan Congress… twirled their moustaches while the good guys in white hats
gathered up their white horses in a circle and…
Argued with each other.
And while they bickered
and succored their private, crazy motives, the locomotive drew closer and
closer to the screaming victims tied to the tracks…
TO BE CONTINUED…
|
JULY 30 – AUGUST
5 |
|
Friday, July 30, 2021 Infected: 34,945,408 Dead:
613,013 Dow:
34,935.47 |
It’s National Cheesecake Day. Also, the 100th Anniversary of
Wheaties. Some U.S. Olympians are
favored to gain box covers (and more medals)… notably backup gymnast Suni Lee, replacement gymnast Mykala
Skinner and swimmer Caeleb Dressell. Overall, Americans hold a slim lead in
medals.
Evictions rise to the level of plague, wildfires and gun violence as American
perils… Joe Biden’s appeal to Congress fails and they trot off on a six week
vacation. At least we are wobbling
closer towards a (slimmed-down) infrastructure bill.
CDC now calls the Delta Variant more contagious than chickenpox,
spreads faster than the common cold and is able to leap tall vaccines in a
single bound (aka breakthroughs).
Super spreader summer at ritzy Provincetown, MA, Dutch music festival
and… soon enough… Chicago’s Lollapallooza, where
fake vaxx ID cards are en vogue (wasn’t the point
of refuseniks that they were manly men who would boast about their
indifference to disease and death?).
At least the economy is booming too… GDP hike best since before the
plague and employers are looking for (cheap) workers. But new lockdowns would imperil that, too. |
|
Saturday, July 31, 2021 Infected:
34,978,276 Dead:
613,080 |
Back to school nearing and
confusion reigns… masks or no masks, vaxxes or no vaxxes, in person or remote learning. Violent local school board meetings add to
chaos. Refusenik Gov. Ron deSantis (R-Fl) orders his own children not to wear
masks. Delta also causing employers to
reimpose mandates and remote employment… which many workers like.
Council on Criminal Justice reports murders up 16%. Atlanta dog walker stabbed to death and her
dog is killed too. Road rager kills teen driver after Astros game and rock
through windshield kills Idaho toddler.
Psycho goes on shooting spree after watching the latest “Purge” movie. TikTok star
assassinated at another cinematic emporium.
Gangs of angry monkeys battle one another in the streets of Thailand.
Quarantined Tokyo Olympians protest prisonlike conditions… cells with
no light, bad food; losers accuse Russians of doping. On the other hand – 100,000 children are
starving to death in Ethiopia. |
|
Sunday, August 1, 2021 Infected:
35,002,148
Dead: 613,224 |
Wishy-washy
authorities blame mis- (not deliberate dis-) information for plague rebound,
finger wagging mediaggots preach: “Don’t
judge!” Plague mastermind Djonald Undeterred raises over 100 million at maskless fundraisers as TreasDep
sends his old tax returns to State and Federal prosecutors. Ex-Dem queen Donna Brazile
goes on Sunday talkshow and says “God help us if we
get to the Omega Variant.” (Movie
producers sit up and take notice.) Five more shot in New Orleans, four year
old killed in Indiana, deadly car ramming in Virginia. But New York takes the weekend prize with
ten (three gang members, intended, seven bystanders), five more in
Nevada. Republicans say it’s all
Pelosi’s fault (like the gays or blacks or Asians killed for just
existing). NHL’s Evander Kane accused
of throwing games to support wife’s gambling habit by… his wife! Nanook the husky who chased the car of the
cruel owner who abandoned him roadside and became viral is rescued and
adopted. |
|
Monday, August 2, 2021 Infected: 35,131,393 Dead: 613,679 Dow: 34,938.16
|
Eviction Day dawns. 3.6M at
risk. Daily plague cases still
rising. Louisiana and Florida worst,
Austin out of hospital beds. NIH
director admits children are dying but vaxx
refuseniks still refuse and the mandates and lockdowns are coming back. “We know what to do,” says Dr. Francis
Collins, “we just need to get the politics out and do it.” Restaurants refuse to serve refuseniks,
corporations fire them and Trump stalwart Sen. Lindsay Graham (R-SC) gets it,
but the no-nos revel in their “martyrdom”. Politics is also stalling the
infrastructure bill but progress… albeit slow… is being made and the
Democrats feel they can round up enough Republican votes to close off the
inevitable filibuster. Third Capitol
riot policeman commits suicide, a fourth follows – Miami cops beat and stomp
a black parking zone violator and an amateur videographer. Long, hot, violent summer looms. |
|
Tuesday, August 3, 2021 Infected: 35,237,950 Dead: 614,295 Dow: 35,116.40 |
America finally reaches President Joe’s
70% deadline – a month late and nine thousand lives short. Kids, experts agree, can catch, spread and
die from the Delta Variant, but bureaucrats insist they have to do more tests
and studies and fill out more forms, with some schools already opening
against a chaotic mishmash of rules and regulations. Twelve kids get it at charter school for vaxxing refuseniks.
Sen. Graham blames his disease on a strategy session cum house party
on Joe (D-WVa) Manchin’s houseboat.
New York report finds Gov. Andrew Cuomo to be “repulsive” and a
lecher, eliciting sentiment from key Democrats (including President Joe) that
he should resign. “I was only trying
to make people smile,” randy Andy replies.
Simone Biles returns to competition and takes a bronze on the balance
beam, with Team America cheering her on.
But women’s soccer team loses to Canada and settles for bronze. |
|
Wednesday, August 4, 2021 Infected: 35,330,664 Dead: 614,785 Dow: 34,792.67 |
CDC
releases alternate plague report that says vaxxes
are up 73%. San Francisco legalizes
booster shots, blames ΔV (Delta Variant) for their defiance of
Washington policymakers. Masks and vaxxes ordered for Disneyland/world and… NASCAR? (Say it ain’t so,
Dale!) Ex-Pres Obama cancels his
massive 60th birthday bash, reviled by many as a celebrity super
spreader. Gov. Cuomo wakes to more calls for
resignation from his former friends. A
TV lawyer calls him “out of control” for blaming the victims and his own
mother for teaching him that groping is an Italian tradition. |
|
Thursday, August 5, 2021 Infected:
35,437,377
Dead: 615,319 Dow: 35,064.25 |
700,000 maniacs converge on Sturgis, SD
for resumptive biker rally beginning tomorrow. Experts predict that plague cases will
bounce back to 200,000/day blaming mass outdoor gatherings and the ΔV. Dr. Fauci
predicts that, without quick approval, more children will get sick and die…
the bureaucrats stick by their paperwork.
Overwhelmed hospitals are cancelling elective surgeries.
Western wildfires blaze… town of Greenville, CA is totally burnt. Temperatures are back up over the 100°
mark.
Impeacher-ers closing in on Cuomo, four
prosecutors in four different counties want a piece of his backside. After his tales of adventure with a female
bodyguard, 60% want him to go.
With their divorces (and monetary issues) behind them, Microsoftee Bill Gates blames his “encounters” with
Jeffrey Epstein, then hooks up with MacKenzie
Scott/Bezos (perhaps already reconsidering her rebound marriage to… a
chemistry teacher). All that’s lacking
is the Beezosliebubba/Melinda coming together… then
there can be a four-way union that puts their combined wealth to 425B (plus
the value of the Gates foundation)… back ahead of upstart champagne and
jewelry magnate Bernard Arnault. |
|
|
|
The dangers of the
Delta Variant conceded, economists, employers and workers all celebrated a
massive half-point drop in the unemployed ledger. That was enough to push the Don into the
black (or green) and that was all. Jobs
aside, there were murder epidemics coast to coast, political paralysis and
climate change causing (take your pick) floods or fires. A climatologist even said that the breakup of
Greenlandic ice was imminent (which would change the course of the gulf stream
and lead to global cooling – which, we suppose, is a good thing.) Sort of like
a massive die off is generating jobs for undertakers and a population fall due
to crashing life expectancies will mean more job openings. And then there is the plague… and the
likelihood of further (and deadlier) variants beyond Delta. At least the American performances at the
Olympics helped mitigate the strange atmosphere of that event.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
CATEGORY |
VALUE |
BASE |
RESULTS |
SCORE |
SCORE |
OUR SOURCES and COMENTS |
||
INCOME |
24% |
6/17/13 |
LAST |
CHANGE |
NEXT |
7/30/21 |
8/6/21 |
SOURCE
|
Wages
(hourly, per capita) |
9% |
1350 points |
7/30/21 |
+0.31% |
8/13/21 |
1,453.83 |
1,453.83 |
|
Median
Income (yearly) |
4% |
600 |
7/30/21 |
+0.03% |
8/13/21 |
671.80 |
672.01 |
http://www.usdebtclock.org/ 35,562 572 583 |
*Unempl. (BLS – in millions |
4% |
600 |
7/30/21 |
-9.76% |
8/13/21 |
339.87 |
371.34 |
http://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS14000000/ 5.9% 5.4% |
*Official (DC – in millions) |
2% |
300 |
7/30/21 |
+0.01% |
8/13/21 |
412.08 |
412.12 |
http://www.usdebtclock.org/ 8.796
9,478 477 |
*Unofficl. (DC – in millions) |
2% |
300 |
7/30/21 |
+0.08% |
8/13/21 |
354.49 |
354.21 |
http://www.usdebtclock.org/ 16,356
368 381 |
Workforce Participtn.
Number
Percent |
2% |
300 |
7/30/21 |
+0.024% +0.415% |
8/13/21 |
316.50 |
317.81 |
In 151,708
741 778 Out 100,243 240 237Total: 251,015 http://www.usdebtclock.org/ 60.22
47 |
WP % (ycharts)* |
1% |
150 |
7/30/21 |
+0.16% |
8/13/21 |
152.23 |
152.48 |
https://ycharts.com/indicators/labor_force_participation_rate
61.60 .70 |
OUTGO |
(15%) |
|||||||
Total
Inflation |
7% |
1050 |
7/30/21 |
+0.9% |
8/13/21 |
985.14 |
985.14 |
http://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.nr0.htm +0.9
nc |
Food |
2% |
300 |
7/30/21 |
+0.8% |
8/13/21 |
278.09 |
278.09 |
http://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.nr0.htm +0.8 |
Gasoline |
2% |
300 |
7/30/21 |
+2.5% |
8/13/21 |
268.80 |
268.80 |
http://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.nr0.htm
-2.5 |
Medical Costs |
2% |
300 |
7/30/21 |
nc |
8/13/21 |
287.06 |
287.06 |
http://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.nr0.htm 0 |
Shelter |
2% |
300 |
7/30/21 |
+0.5% |
8/13/21 |
289.93 |
289.93 |
http://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.nr0.htm +0.5 |
WEALTH |
(6%) |
|
||||||
Dow Jones Index |
2% |
300 |
7/30/21 |
+0.75% |
8/13/21 |
378.32 |
378.10 |
|
Home (Sales)
(Valuation) |
1% 1% |
150 150 |
5/21/21 |
+1.03% +3.71% |
8/13/21 |
170.29 182.84 |
170.29 182.84 |
https://www.nar.realtor/research-and-statistics Sales
(M): 5.86 Valuations
(K): 363.3 nc |
Debt
(Personal) |
2% |
300 |
7/30/21 |
+0.087% |
8/13/21 |
272.70 |
272.56 |
http://www.usdebtclock.org/ 64,608
664 |
|
||||||||
AMERICAN ECONOMIC
INDEX (15% of TOTAL INDEX POINTS) |
||||||||
NATIONAL |
(10%) |
|
||||||
Revenue (trilns.) |
2% |
300 |
7/30/21 |
+0.14% |
8/13/21 |
310.85 |
311.28 |
debtclock.org/ 3,635
640 |
Expenditures
(tr.) |
2% |
300 |
7/30/21 |
+0.10% |
8/13/21 |
219.31 |
219.09 |
debtclock.org/ 6,823
830 |
National Debt
tr.) |
3% |
450 |
7/30/21 |
+0.11% |
8/13/21 |
321.93 |
321.58 |
http://www.usdebtclock.org/ 28,579
610 |
Aggregate Debt
(tr.) |
3% |
450 |
7/30/21 |
+0.12% |
8/13/21 |
370.15 |
369.72 |
http://www.usdebtclock.org/ 85,424
523 |
GLOBAL |
(5%) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Foreign Debt
(tr.) |
2% |
300 |
7/30/21 |
+0.04% |
8/13/21 |
292.30 |
292.18 |
http://www.usdebtclock.org/ 7,098
101 |
Exports (in
billions) |
1% |
150 |
7/30/21 |
+0.825% |
8/13/21 |
182.97 |
184.48 |
|
Imports (bl.) |
1% |
150 |
7/30/21 |
- 2.15% |
8/13/21 |
119.13 |
116.57 |
|
Trade Deficit
(bl.) |
1% |
150 |
7/30/21 |
- 5.95% |
8/13/21 |
97.15 |
91.37 |
https://www.census.gov/foreign-trade/index.html
71.2 75.7 |
SOCIAL INDICES
(40%) |
||||||||
ACTS
of MAN |
(12%) |
|
||||||
World
Affairs |
3% |
450 |
7/30/21 |
-0.5% |
8/13/21 |
392.21 |
390.25 |
Another
coup in Myanmar. 100,000 children
starving to death in Ethiopia.
Sprinter from Belarus seeks asylum at Tokyo’s Polish embassy. |
Terrorism |
2% |
300 |
7/30/21 |
-0.5% |
8/13/21 |
234.77 |
233.60 |
Killer
drone strikes oil tanker off Omani coast – Iran blamed. Taliban routing Afghan army in village
after village. Lebanon “celebrates” one year anniversary of massive explosion
by firing rockets at Israel, |
Politics |
3% |
450 |
7/30/21 |
-0.2% |
8/13/21 |
440.37 |
439.49 |
Bipartisan
infrastructure talks go on and on and on.
Refusenik Gov. deSantis (R-Fl) orders his
children to be “tough” and not to wear masks or accept vaxxes. |
Economics |
3% |
450 |
7/30/21 |
-0.1% |
8/13/21 |
405.81 |
405.49 |
GDP soars
higher than before plague. But sales
slump for Amazon after expose; for Ben & Jerry after they denounce
Islamic nations and for companies pushing back to work reopening back due to
ΔV. Boeing Starliner
joins space tourism race. Spirit
Airlines’ “operational challenges” strand Earth tourists day after day after
day. Frontier Airlines duct tapes
violent passenger to seat. Scarlett
Johansson sues Disney over theatrical v. streaming royalty arrangements. |
Crime |
1% |
150 |
7/30/21 |
-0.7% |
8/13/21 |
245.54 |
243.82 |
Council on
Criminal Justice finds murder up 16% over 2020. Stabber kills cop then other cops kill
stabber at Pentagon subway station.
Dog walker and dog stabbed to death in Atlanta, 10 shot in NYC, 3
killed in S. Car., road rager kills teen driving
home from Astros game, overpass rock through windshield kills Idaho child,
psycho goes on shooting spree after watching “Purge” movies, TikTok star assassinated in Cal., movie theater, gunman
groom in tuxedo wastes two in New Orleans.
Treasury Dept. forwards Trump tax returns to prosecutors. NHL star Kane accused of throwing games to
support wife’s gambling habit. |
ACTS
of GOD |
(6%) |
|
||||||
Environment/Weather |
3% |
450 |
7/30/21 |
-0.1% |
8/13/21 |
406.51 |
406.10 |
Heat and
fire back in the West, flash flooding and mudslides Midwest from Canada to
Mexico border. 120° in Palm
Springs. Deodorants said to destroy
the ozone layer, prompting a stampede of ozone lawyers. |
Natural/Unnatural
Disaster |
3% |
450 |
7/30/21 |
-0.3% |
8/13/21 |
405.69 |
404.47 |
Oregon
firefighters “making progress”.
California’s… not so: Greenville is destroyed. Colorado mudslides strand hundreds of cars
overnight. New farming regulations
prompt bacon shortage. Texas van crash
kills ten “migrants”. Wall collapse at
Tennessee Titanic museum injures three – sends believers to rereading
Leviticus. The real Titanic underwater
wreck said to be “disintegrating”. |
LIFESTYLE/JUSTICE INDEX (15%) |
||||||||
Science,
Tech, Education |
4% |
600 |
7/30/21 |
-0.2% |
8/13/21 |
678.67 |
677.31 |
Chaos
reigns as schools reopen – different rules: not only for different
communities, but for students, teachers, custodians, bus drivers etc. |
Equality
(econ/social) |
4% |
600 |
7/30/21 |
-0.1% |
8/13/21 |
562.15 |
561.59 |
Dolly
Parton invests “I Will Always…” royalties in black Nashville
neighborhood. Five Miami cops stomp
black parking violator, then do the same to a bystander who photographed
them. Amazon warehouse workers said to
be mulling another union
election. |
Health Plague |
4% |
600 |
7/30/21 |
-0.1% -0.1% |
8/13/21 |
500.22 - 102.30 |
499.72 - 102.20 |
Study reveals dogs know when people are lying. Warning
on depression pill Rexulti – may cause “unnatural
urges”. US finally reaches President Joe’s 70% vaxx rate.
Breakthrough cases spiking, but vaxxed
victims getting less sick than the refuseniks. “I should have gotten the damn vaccine,” a
dying man texts… parents are snatching illegal vaxxes
for their kids. “Lock them up?” South African Olympic golfer and Yankees
pitcher get it. A thousand of the 20K
attendees at Dutch rockfest get it. Ex-DNC chair Donna Brazile
says: “God help us if we get to an Omega Variant!” |
Freedom and
Justice |
3% |
450 |
7/30/21 |
-0.2% |
8/13/21 |
461.41 |
460.49 |
Third
Capitol Riot policeman commits suicide as Pelosi panel probes this and
that. They are awarded gold medals,
but 21 Republicans stomp their feet and say “No!” National ASPCA accused of hoarding 280M and
giving nada to local shelters. Three
of four Floyd killers ask for their trials to be separated from that of Ofc.
Chauvin. Gov. Mike Parson
(R-Mo) pardons gun-wielding St.
Louis couple who menaced riotous home invaders. |
MISCELLANEOUS and TRANSIENT INDEX (7%) |
||||||||
Cultural
incidents |
3% |
450 |
7/30/21 |
+0.2% |
8/13/21 |
523.14 |
524.19 |
MTV turns
40, nostalgiacs remember “when they actually played
music videos. Rapper Da Baby says Da
Bad Word, evicted from Da Covidpalooza. Olympic snapshots: Italian and Qatari tie
in high jump, agree to share Da Gold.
Simone Biles and US women’s soccer gain bronzes. Rihanna’s cosmetics “sideline” makes her
the richest woman in America at 1.7B… Reese Witherspoon 2nd, Kim
K. down to 3rd. |
Miscellaneous
incidents |
4% |
450 |
7/30/21 |
-0.2% |
8/13/21 |
484.53 |
483.56 |
Ikea to
sell candles that smell like Swedish meatballs. Gangs of monkeys battle on the streets of
Thailand. Nanook, the car-chasing
abandoned husky finds a forever home. Tabloid
economists wonder: Will MacKenzie divorce her
chemistry teacher and marry Bill Gates… will Jeff hook up with Melinda? And if both couples marry, which team will
be richest? |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The
Don Jones Index for the week of July 30th through August 5th, 2021 was UP 14.38 points.
The Don Jones Index is
sponsored by the Coalition for a New Consensus: retired Congressman and
Independent Presidential candidate Jack “Catfish” Parnell, Chairman; Brian
Doohan, Administrator. The CNC denies,
emphatically, allegations that the organization, as well as any of its officers
(including former Congressman Parnell, environmentalist/America-Firster Austin
Tillerman and cosmetics CEO Rayna Finch) and references to Parnell’s works,
“Entropy and Renaissance” and “The Coming Kill-Off” are fictitious or, at best,
mere pawns in the web-serial “Black Helicopters” – and promise swift, effective
legal action against parties promulgating this and/or other such slanders.
Comments, complaints, donations (especially SUPERPAC
donations) always welcome at feedme@generisis.com or: speak@donjonesindex.com
ATTACHMENT ONE –
From Fox News
At least 10 states have
their own eviction freezes in place – although some of those protections are
poised to lapse soon. Here's a closer look:
California: Roughly 1.6 million individuals – or about 14%
of the state's population – who are behind on their rent will be protected from
eviction through the end of September. Beginning in October, landlords will be
able to remove people from their homes.
Hawaii: The state has halted evictions through Aug. 6,
after which 26,000 individuals could be evicted.
Illinois: An eviction moratorium in Illinois will phase
out by the end of August, although landlords were allowed to start filing for
eviction orders at the beginning of the month. There are about 459,000 renters
who are behind on their payments in the state.
Maryland: Renters in Maryland are protected from
evictions through Aug. 15. About 18% of the state, or 228,000 individuals, are
not caught up on rent.
Minnesota: There are some 93,000 people who are
behind on their rent in Minnesota; they will be protected from evictions
through Sept. 12, although a so-called eviction "off-ramp" begins
Aug. 13.
New
Jersey: The eviction ban in
New Jersey will remain in place until the official end of the public health
emergency designation – which expires in October – plus an additional two
months. That means some 390,000 individuals will be protected from evictions
until the end of the year.
New
Mexico: The state Supreme
Court in New Mexico has not yet set an expiration date for the eviction
moratorium that's protecting about 72,000 renters who owe money to their
landlords.
New
York: Roughly 1.2 million
New York renters who are behind on their rent are shielded by an eviction
moratorium that's in place through Aug. 31.
Oregon: Oregonians cannot currently be evicted for
rent owed between the months of April 2020 and June 2021; individuals who owe
money over that time frame have until the end of February 2022 to cover it.
Washington: About 290,000 renters in Washington need to catch
up on unpaid rent. The state has a freeze on evictions in place through Sept.
30.
ATTACHMENT TWO –
From mofo.com
Update: FEDERAL JUDGE IN D.C. SETS
ASIDE THE CDC NATIONWIDE EVICTION MORATORIUM
06 May 2021
On May 5, 2021, Federal District Judge Dabney Friedrich vacated the Centers
for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) nationwide moratorium on
residential evictions (the “Order”), which the CDC had recently extended beyond its congressionally
approved expiration date of March 31 to June 30, 2021 (Alabama Association
of Realtors, et al. v. U.S. Dep’t of Health and Human Services, et
al., Case No. 1:20-cv-03377, United States District Court for the District
of Columbia). While Judge Friedrich is but one of several federal judges to
rule against the Order as highlighted in our March 4, 2021 and March 15, 2021 alerts, her decision is
arguably the most extensive. Though no more favorable to the CDC than Judge
Friedrich’s vacatur order, the holdings out of federal courts in Ohio and Texas
at least were limited to the plaintiffs with standing before those courts.
Here, Judge Friedrich refused a request by the Department of Justice (DOJ) for
similar treatment and held that the CDC Order must be set aside: “[The D.C.
Circuit] has instructed that when ‘regulations are unlawful, the ordinary
result is that the rules are vacated—not that their application to the
individual petitioner is proscribed’” (citing Nat’l Mining Ass’n v. U.S. Army Corps of Eng’rs,
145 F.3d 1399, 1409 (D.C. Cir. 1998)).
The Alabama Association decision was based
primarily on Judge Friedrich’s reading of the Public Health Services Act, 42 U.S.C. § 264(a) (the
“Act”), pursuant to which the
CDC first issued the Order in September 2020. Specifically, the federal court
found that the Act, by its plain terms, did not expressly indicate congressional
intent to vest the CDC with authority to impose a national eviction moratorium.
Because the decision to ban evictions is one of “vast economic and political
significance,” Judge Friedrich maintained, Congress could not be said to have
delegated it without having made its intention to do so explicit.
The DOJ has announced that it
has “already filed a notice of appeal of the decision [to the Court of Appeals
for the District of Columbia Circuit] and intends to seek an emergency stay of
the order pending appeal.”
We will continue to monitor these cases and provide updates as
they become available.
Update (May 6,
2021): Judge
Friedrich has just stayed her decision pending the DOJ appeal.
Update (June 3,
2021): On June 2, 2021, the United States Court of Appeals for the
District of Columbia Circuit (the “D.C. Circuit”) opted to keep the CDC’s
nationwide eviction moratorium in place during the appeals process.
A three-judge panel for the D.C. Circuit issued the per curiam order affirming the stay Judge
Friedrich granted on May 6, 2021 over objections by the plaintiffs, a coalition
of Alabama landlords and realtors. In filing their motion to vacate the stay,
the plaintiffs had hoped to prevent the CDC from enforcing its Order, which
expires on June 30, 2021, at least until a final ruling on the DOJ’s appeal.
Instead, the D.C. Circuit found that Judge Friedrich had not abused her
discretion in granting the stay, largely because, in the court’s opinion, the
government had “made a strong showing that it is likely to succeed on the
merits, [since] Congress has expressly recognized that the [CDC] had the
authority to issue its narrowly crafted moratorium under [the Act].” In further
support of its order, the court also underscored the plaintiffs’ failure to
prove that the stay might cause irreparable harm to their interests such that
reversing Judge Friedrich’s decision would be appropriate: “The record does not
demonstrate any likelihood that [the plaintiffs] themselves will lose their
businesses, that an appreciable percentage of their own tenants who would
otherwise pay in full will be unable to repay back rent, or that financial
shortfalls are unlikely ultimately to be mitigated.”
While not meant to resolve “the ultimate merits of the legal
question” at issue, the D.C. Circuit’s order suggests that the court may rule
in the government’s favor when it finally does consider the appeal of Judge
Friedrich’s ruling, whereby she vacated the CDC’s eviction ban on statutory
grounds: “[The Department of Health and Human Services] has demonstrated that
lifting the national moratorium will exacerbate the significant public health
risks identified by the CDC because, even with increased vaccinations, COVID-19
continues to spread and infect persons, and new variants are emerging.”
We will continue to monitor this case and will provide further
updates as they become available.
Michael Machado, a Law Clerk in our New York office, contributed
to the writing of this alert.
Editor’s Note: mofo.com is
the URL for the law firm of Morrison and Foerster, not what some might be
thinking.
ATTACHMENT THREE – From SCOTUS
Cite as: 594 U. S.
____ (2021) 1 KAVANAUGH, J., concurring SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
_________________ No. 20A169 _________________ ALABAMA ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS,
ET AL. v. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES, ET AL. ON APPLICATION TO
VACATE STAY [June 29, 2021] The application to vacate stay presented to THE
CHIEF JUSTICE and by him referred to the Court is denied. JUSTICE THOMAS,
JUSTICE ALITO, JUSTICE GORSUCH, and JUSTICE BARRETT would grant the
application. JUSTICE KAVANAUGH, concurring. I agree with the District Court and
the applicants that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention exceeded its
existing statutory authority by issuing a nationwide eviction moratorium. See
Utility Air Regulatory Group v. EPA, 573 U. S. 302, 324 (2014). Because the CDC
plans to end the moratorium in only a few weeks, on July 31, and because those
few weeks will allow for additional and more orderly distribution of the
congressionally appropriated rental assistance funds, I vote at this time to
deny the application to vacate the District Court’s stay of its order. See
Barnes v. E-Systems, Inc. Group Hospital Medical & Surgical Ins. Plan, 501
U. S. 1301, 1305 (1991) (Scalia, J., in chambers) (stay depends in part on
balance of equities); Coleman v. Paccar Inc., 424 U. S. 1301, 1304 (1976)
(Rehnquist, J., in chambers). In my view, clear and
specific congressional authorization (via new legislation) would be
necessary for the CDC to extend the moratorium past July 31.
ATTACHMENT FOUR – From Fox News
BIDEN IGNORES PELOSI'S CALL
TO EXTEND EVICTION BAN DESPITE KAVANAUGH OPINION
'Squad' Dems still
protesting inaction from party leaders outside Capitol
By Tyler Olson
President
Biden and the White House as of Monday morning didn't respond to
a statement from House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and her leadership team
calling on the executive branch to extend the federal eviction moratorium,
as "Squad" Democrats continued to camp on the Capitol steps
in protest of the inaction from their party.
"Action is
needed, and it must come from the Administration. That is why House leadership
is calling on the Administration to immediately extend the moratorium,"
Pelosi, D-Calif., and her leadership team said in a Sunday morning statement
hours after the moratorium ended. "As the CDC doubles down on mask-wearing
and vaccination efforts, science and reason demand that they must also extend
the moratorium in light of the delta variant."
The Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) early in
the coronavirus pandemic implemented an eviction moratorium that
banned landlords from removing people who were behind on their rent. It was
extended multiple times but finally ended Saturday night following a June
opinion from Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh saying Congress –
not the president -- would have to extend the moratorium if it were to
continue.
Consistent with that,
the White House asked Congress to pass legislation continuing the ban on
landlords evicting tenants who fail to pay their rent.
"In light of the
Supreme Court’s ruling, the President calls on Congress to extend the eviction
moratorium to protect such vulnerable renters and their families without
delay," White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki said last week.
But the votes were not
there in either the House or the Senate, so the eviction ban expired. The White
House did not respond to a request for comment from Fox News about Pelosi's
statement, which essentially asked Biden to do something the Supreme Court
already said is unlawful.
Progressive Democrats
in the House of Representatives, meanwhile, are livid at their party leadership
for allegedly not taking the eviction moratorium seriously. Sunday night marked
their third night protesting lack of action by Biden and Democrats in Congress
by camping out on the steps of the Capitol.
"5 AM. This
morning felt cold, like the wind was blowing straight through my sleeping
bag," Rep. Cori Bush, D-Mo., tweeted Monday morning. "Since
Friday—when some colleagues chose early vacation over voting to prevent
evictions—we’ve been at the Capitol. It’s an eviction emergency. Our people
need an eviction moratorium. Now."
Bush said in a Sunday
night tweet that she'd heard there were "thousands" of evictions on
the first day after the moratorium lifted, with "potentially millions to
come."
"People are being
forcibly removed from their homes RIGHT NOW," she said.
Rep. Alexandria
Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., says Democratic leadership could have extended the
moratorium if it had the will to.
"Everybody knew
this was coming," she said Friday at the protest. "We were sounding
the alarm about this issue. The court order was not yesterday, the court order
was not Monday, the court order was about a month ago."
"The White House
says it doesn't have authority to extend the eviction moratorium or cancel
student debt," Rep. Jamaal Bowman, D-N.Y., tweeted Sunday night. "But
it hasn’t had a problem conducting airstrikes without authorization from Congress."
It's unclear what
steps either Congress or the White House could take next on the now-lapsed
moratorium. The House of Representatives is scheduled to be out of session for
nearly the entire month of August.
The White House, meanwhile,
is trying to get lower levels of government to help renters with money that's
already been allocated by Congress.
"The American
Rescue Plan allocated an additional $21.5 billion for Emergency Rental
Assistance (ERA) that can be used by renters to cover arrears and make
landlords whole. This is on top of $25 billion allocated under the Consolidated
Appropriations Act," a White House press release said last month.
"But state and local governments must do better. Money is available in every
state to help renters who are behind on rent and at risk of eviction."
Fox News' Jason Donner
contributed to this report.
ATTACHMENT FIVE – From the Associated Press
EVICTIONS EXPECTED TO SPIKE AS PANDEMIC MORATORIUM
ENDS
By MICHAEL CASEY
BOSTON (AP) — Evictions, which have mostly
been on pause during the pandemic, were expected to ramp up Monday after the
Biden administration allowed the federal moratorium to expire over the weekend
and Congress was unable to do anything to extend it.
Housing advocates fear the end of the Centers
for Disease Control and Prevention moratorium could result in millions of
people being evicted. But most expect the wave of evictions to build slowly
over the coming weeks and months as the bureaucracy of removing people from
their homes restarts.
On Sunday night, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi
and the House Democratic leaders called on the Biden administration to
immediately extend the moratorium, calling it a “moral imperative” to prevent
Americans from being put out of their homes during a COVID-19 surge.
The Biden administration announced Thursday it
would allow the ban to expire, arguing its hands were tied after the U.S.
Supreme Court signaled the measure had to end.
“Struggling renters are now facing a health crisis
and an eviction crisis,” said Alicia Mazzara, a
senior research analyst at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.
“Without the CDC’s moratorium, millions of
people are at risk of being evicted or becoming homeless, increasing their
exposure to COVID just as cases are rising across the country. The effects will
fall heavily on people of color, particularly Black and Latino communities, who
face greater risk of eviction and more barriers to vaccination.”
More than 15 million people live in households
that owe as much as $20 billion to their landlords, according to the Aspen
Institute. As of July 5, roughly 3.6 million people in the U.S. said they faced
eviction in the next two months, according to the U.S. Census Bureau’s
Household Pulse Survey.
Parts of the South and other regions with
weaker tenant protections will likely see the largest spikes and communities of
color where vaccination rates are sometimes lower will be hit hardest. But
advocates say this crisis is likely to have a wider impact than pre-pandemic
evictions.
The Biden administration had hoped that
historic amounts of rental assistance allocated by Congress in December and
March would help avert an eviction crisis. But the distribution has been
painfully slow. Only about $3 billion of the first tranche of $25 billion had
been distributed through June by states and localities. Another $21.5 billion
will go to the states.
Ashley Phonsyry, 22,
who will be in court Thursday for an eviction hearing after falling several
thousands dollars behind on her Fayetteville, Arkansas, two-bedroom apartment,
said her landlord refused to take rental assistance. She left her job after
being hurt in a domestic violence incident and suffering from depression and
anxiety. The eviction hearing is a day after her domestic violence case goes to
court.
“It frustrates me and scares me,” she said of
being evicted. “I’m trying so hard to make it right and it doesn’t seem like
it’s enough.”
Around the country, courts, legal advocates
and law enforcement agencies are gearing up for evictions to return to
pre-pandemic levels, a time when 3.7 million people were displaced from their
homes every year, or seven every minute, according to the Eviction Lab at
Princeton University.
In St. Louis, where the sheriff’s office handles
court-ordered evictions, Sheriff Vernon Betts said 126 evictions had been
ordered pending the end of the moratorium. His office plans to enforce about 30
evictions per day starting Aug. 9.
Betts knows there will be hundreds of
additional orders soon. He’s already been contacted by countless landlords who
haven’t yet filed for eviction, but plan to. And he expected to increase his
staffing.
“What we’re planning on doing is tripling our
two-man team,” he said. “Right off the bat we want to clean up that 126
evictions.”
Sgt. William Brown, who leads the evictions
unit for the Milwaukee County Sheriff’s Office, expects many evictions to
follow the end of the moratorium. He rattled off statistics that showed the
steep decline in evictions since the pandemic began: nearly 4,000 in 2018 and
2019, then a plunge to about 1,900 in 2020.
“I think that once evictions are there fully,
there’s no more moratorium in place, it’s going to get really bad,” he said.
“It’s the most challenging position that I’ve
ever been in, because at the end of the day I have an empathy and sympathy. I’m
required by state statute to execute this,” he said. “You have to feel for
these people ... watching small kids go through this, this entire process.”
Lee Camp, an attorney with the St. Louis legal
group ArchCity Defenders, said the vast majority of
tenants facing eviction don’t have lawyers, often because they can’t afford
them. Meanwhile, he said, eviction cases move through the courts quickly in
Missouri, often in a matter of weeks.
“The scales of justice are just at this
incredible imbalance,” Camp said.
In Wisconsin, Heiner Giese, legal counsel for
the Apartment Association of Southeastern Wisconsin, said his trade association
for rental property owners in the Milwaukee area has been “very strong in
urging our members and all landlords not to evict.”
“I pretty strongly believe from the feedback
we get from our members in the Milwaukee area … there will not be this giant
tsunami of (evictions),” Giese said.
Still, Colleen Foley, executive director of
the Legal Aid Society of Milwaukee, said she “certainly” expects an uptick. She
said 161 evictions were filed last week, a significant increase from prior
weeks where filings tended to hover around 100 to 120.
ATTACHMENT SIX (A) – From CNBC
RENT CONTROLS ARE BECOMING A HIGHLY DIVISIVE ISSUE IN EUROPE
By Silvia Amaro PUBLISHED THU, JUL 29 20211:36 AM EDT
·
·
Colm Lauder, head of real
estate at investment bank Goodbody, told CNBC that he expects rental prices to keep rising. He said: “In
Ireland, we are concerned that [rent] controls will stop capital coming through.”
·
Barbara Steenbergen, a member of
the International Union of Tenants and former lawmaker for the German region of Cologne, told CNBC: “We are of course
pro rent controls if it’s part of a
comprehensive housing package.”
LONDON
— Rent controls are becoming increasingly popular in many European nations, but
experts note that they rarely solve housing crises on their own and can even
scare investors away.
Rent
controls are government policies, whether on local or a national level, that
aim to cap house price increases. They are intended to keep housing affordable,
at least for the most vulnerable parts of a population. However, the policy has
its critics.
In
Sweden, for example, rent controls effectively
toppled the government there.
(See below) In Germany, the matter was
subject to a year-long legal battle. Meanwhile, lawmakers in the Netherlands,
the U.K. and Ireland have all had similar discussions about their property
markets.
The root causes
Speaking
about lofty prices in the Netherlands, Nic Vrieselaar,
a senior economist at RaboResearch, told CNBC that
the market is “becoming unacceptable.” “This is a matter of supply-demand due
to the low interest rate environment,” he said.
There’s
an age-old trend of people flocking to urban areas where there’s more jobs and
higher salaries. But, at a time of low interest rates from central banks —
which European nations have experienced in the wake of the sovereign debt
crisis — and help-to-buy schemes, more people have bought property, either as a
first home or as an investment to let. This demand then pushes up prices given
the limited housing stock on the market.
In
addition, the so-called “Airbnb effect” has worsened the situation, experts
note. Rather than selling a property or letting it out long term, many
landlords choose to make their houses or apartments available for short stays.
This then means there’s less stock for the locals, thus contributing to a
further acceleration of rental prices.
Between
2010 and the first quarter of 2021, rents increased by 15.3% in the European Union,
according to Eurostat.
Separate data gathered by Europe’s
statistics office showed that, in 2020, the estimated average rent levels for
apartments was the highest in Dublin, followed by Copenhagen, then Paris,
Luxembourg and Stockholm.
Colm Lauder, head of real estate at investment bank
Goodbody, told CNBC that he expects rental prices to keep rising. He said: “In
Ireland, we are concerned that [rent] controls will stop capital coming
through.”
A vicious cycle
Property
investors see a significant downside in rent controls in that they cap returns.
In the case of Ireland, rent increases in certain areas are limited at 4% per
year.
“If
they can’t get [returns] then they will look elsewhere,” Lauder said.
Private
investment plays a crucial role in supporting the housing market, by promoting
construction and refurbishment. If investors find higher returns in other
nations, they are likely to shift their funds there and supply will remain
limited in that initial market.
However,
not everybody agrees with this view.
Barbara
Steenbergen, a member of the International Union of
Tenants and former lawmaker for the German region of Cologne, told CNBC: “We
are of course pro rent controls if it’s part of a comprehensive housing
package.”
She
highlighted how important rent controls are for low and middle-income families,
noting that in Berlin, for example, rent increases have gone up exponentially,
but salaries have not.
This
divide is a “threat to social peace,” she said, while adding that she has not
seen investment fleeing in any market that has rent controls. One of the
challenges is that investors focus on luxury buildings and less on affordable
and social housing, she said.
Ultimately,
the solution may lay with the root of the problem.
“What
I think needs to be done is increasing supply,” Vrieselaar
said.
In a
statement published in 2018, the European Central Bank noted that “housing
completions in the euro area have remained substantially below their average
level since the start of monetary union” in 1999. In addition, the ECB also
said that the lack of building permits and labor shortages have been a
constraint in improving supply.
But Vrieselaar suggested that governments should change the way
they tax the sector, so they can better tackle the housing crisis. Essentially,
he believes that the Netherlands should tax people’s wealth more, including
their second and third homes and lower the burden on people’s incomes so
tenants have more room to spend on their rent.
ATTACHMENT SIX (B) – From Reuters
SWEDISH PM LOFVEN OUSTED IN PARLIAMENT NO-CONFIDENCE VOTE
PUBLISHED
MON, JUN 21 2021 7:09 AM EDT
KEY POINTS
·
The
nationalist Sweden Democrats had seized the chance to call the vote after the
formerly communist Left Party withdrew support for the centre-left government
over a plan to ease rent controls for new-build apartments.
·
The
no-confidence motion, which required 175 votes in the 349-seat parliament to
pass, was supported by 181 lawmakers.
·
Lofven, 63, is the first Swedish
prime minister to be ousted by a no-confidence motion put forward by the
opposition.
Sweden’s
parliament ousted Prime Minister Stefan Lofven in a
no-confidence vote on Monday, giving the Social Democrat leader a week to
resign and hand the speaker the job of finding a new government, or call a snap
election.
The nationalist
Sweden Democrats had seized the chance to call the vote after the formerly
communist Left Party withdrew support for the centre-left government over a
plan to ease rent controls for new-build apartments.
Sweden Democrat
leader Jimmie Akesson told parliament the government
was harmful and historically weak, adding: “It should never have come into
power.”
The no-confidence
motion, which required 175 votes in the 349-seat parliament to pass, was
supported by 181 lawmakers.
Lofven, 63, is the first Swedish prime minister to be ousted by a
no-confidence motion put forward by the opposition. He was due to hold a news
conference later on Monday.
Prime Minister
Stefan Lofven’s “shaky” minority coalition with the
Green Party had relied on support in parliament from two small centre-right
parties and the Left Party since a tight election in the European Union member
state in 2018, according to Reuters.
The Left Party
blamed Lofven for triggering the crisis.
“It is not the
Left Party that has given up on the Social Democrat government, it is the
Social Democrat government that has given up on the Left Party and the Swedish
people,” Left Party leader Nooshi Dadgostar
said.
With parliament
deadlocked, it is not clear to whom the speaker might turn to form a new
government if Lofven resigns. Opinion polls suggest
the centre-left and centre-right blocs are evenly balanced, so a snap election
might not bring clarity either.
Dadgostar said that even though her party had voted against Lofven, it would never help “a right-wing nationalist
government” take power.
A new government
- or a caretaker administration - would sit only until a parliamentary election
scheduled for September next year.
ATTACHMENT SEVEN – From the New York Times
NEW YORK IS PUSHING HOMELESS PEOPLE OFF THE STREETS.
WHERE WILL THEY GO?
Cleanup crews are clearing
encampments, but advocates say the sweeps just move people from one place to
another and fail to address the housing crisis.
By Andy Newman and Nicole Hong Aug.
2, 2021, 3:00 a.m. ET
On a sweltering July afternoon, a homeless man named Melvin
Douglas biked up to his sleeping spot beneath the High Line, the elevated,
art-filled New York park overlooking the Hudson River, and found that a city
cleanup crew had thrown away his possessions — again. The same thing had
happened the day before.
“Brand-new clothes, brand-new T-shirts, everything,” Mr.
Douglas, 54, said as he shook his head at the bare sidewalk. “They took all my
stuff, bro. No regard at all.”
As the country’s most populous city strives to lure back
tourists and office workers, it has undertaken an aggressive campaign to push
homeless people off the streets of Manhattan.
City workers used to tear down one or two encampments a day.
Now, they sometimes clear dozens. Since late May, teams that include sanitation
workers in garbage trucks, police officers and outreach workers have cruised
Manhattan around the clock, hitting the same spots over and over.
The sweeps are part of a broader effort by Mayor Bill de
Blasio that includes transferring over 8,000
people from hotels, where they had been placed to
stem the spread of the coronavirus, to barracks-style group shelters. The transfers
are continuing despite the recent surge in the Delta
variant of the virus, though the city told a judge it
would delay the moves Monday to address concerns that it was not adequately
considering people’s health problems and disabilities.
The city is also responding to months of complaints about
homeless people blocking and befouling public spaces, menacing passers-by and
committing random assaults.
On Wednesday, Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo, whose administration has slashed aid for
addressing homelessness, cited the problem as one of the main hurdles to the
city’s recovery. “We have to get homelessness under control,” he said.
The debate over how to tackle homelessness in New York City,
where over 2,000 people live on the streets and the subway, comes as cities across the country grapple
with growing encampments. On Wednesday, the Los
Angeles City Council outlawed camping near parks,
libraries and schools.
On Saturday, a national eviction
moratorium expired, sparking fears of a new surge in
homelessness, though in New York the moratorium continues through Aug. 31.
The city’s Department of Homeless Services says it resorts to
cleanups only in the case of “service-resistant individuals” and is committed
to helping people find homes.
“The name of the game
is compassionate, consistent outreach,” Bill Neidhardt,
a spokesman for the mayor, said in a statement. “The end goal is always
permanent housing.”
But the city’s ability to offer people such housing is
limited, and the process is slow. And advocates for homeless people and some
city employees say the sweeps accomplish little more than chasing people from
one spot to another, upending already precarious lives and — by blurring
outreach and enforcement — discouraging people from accepting help.
“They are trying to make life so miserable on the streets
that people will come into shelters, but that is a cruel and ineffective approach,”
said Josh Dean, the founder of Human.nyc, a policy group focused on street
homelessness. “People need to trust outreach workers, and this approach is
destroying trust.”
The cleanups also defy Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention Covid-19
recommendations against displacing people who live
outdoors unless they are being moved to “individual housing.” Covid-19 has
killed over 120 homeless people in the city and has infected more than 4,100,
officials say.
According to a statement from the homeless services
department, the cleanup crews do not throw away people’s belongings.
Rather, they “carefully assess” a site while noting the
“number and type of possessions,” remove items to protect “valuable property”
and “quality-of-life for the client,” and provide “details about how they can
obtain the property.”
Max Goren, who lives in Tompkins Square Park in the East
Village, has found reality to be a bit different.
“At least once a week, a sanitation truck rolls up,” Mr.
Goren, 34, said in July. “If you’re not there to say, ‘Hey, that’s mine’,
everything goes in the back.”
He said his possessions had been trashed three times — each
time because he left them to go to a methadone clinic.
“Do I want to risk losing all of my clothes and all my
bedding, or do I miss my clinic appointment?” he said.
“I think it’s an
effort to get us to leave,” he said. “But where are we going to go? If I had
some place to go, I wouldn’t be here.”
In Times Square, the city’s tourist center, a business group
is testing a very different approach.
There, teams of people, some of whom were previously
homeless or incarcerated, hand out T-shirts, socks, granola bars and water,
hoping to build trust and, gradually, connect homeless people to social
services. They only offer services if people ask.
The idea for the program, which recently won a $350,000 city
grant, originated with Tom Harris, a retired police officer and the president
of the Times Square Alliance, a nonprofit that promotes businesses in the area.
Last year, Mr. Harris watched in dismay as street homelessness and open drug
use increased in the area. At some outdoor dining tables, people took food off
customers’ plates.
“The status quo was
untenable,” he said.
But Mr. Harris was determined not to rely on the police. His
view was informed by decades as an officer in Brooklyn, where he found that the
most effective way to stop someone from committing robberies, for example, was
to address underlying problems like addiction.
Working with the Midtown Community Court, which provides
alternatives to jail for those accused of low-level crimes, Mr. Harris helped
create Community First, a program that can refer people to nonprofits that
offer housing or rehabilitation for people with mental illness.
After meeting with 136 homeless people, Community First
teams found a stunning array of systemic problems. Some people had been
released from jail without IDs or stable housing. Many struggled with substance
abuse.
“We’re not going to tear down your home that you built out
of boxes,” said Lauren Curatolo, the community
court’s project director. “We want to support you so that you eventually want
to have a bed in a space.”
For one man sleeping outside a Broadway theater, it took
team members about a dozen visits — after showing up repeatedly with
applesauce, his favorite snack — before he entered a homeless shelter and took
a job training course.
People who are homeless and their advocates say that what
they want, mainly, is something that is in short supply: a place to live with a
modicum of privacy. The best that outreach workers can typically offer is a
berth in a group shelter where 10 to 20 people often (share)
a bedroom.
Since early 2020, the city shelter system has added more
than 1,300 beds in single- or double-occupancy rooms that have drawn people in
off the streets. But thousands more units are needed, the Coalition for the
Homeless said.
One afternoon in June, a Community First team encountered
Richard Birthwright, who said he had lost his job at
a meat plant in North Carolina, returned to New York and started to sleep in
the street.
When a housing specialist told Mr. Birthwright,
54, that there was little long-term housing for people who had been in the
street for under a year and suggested a group shelter, he tensed up. He said
that shelter workers were disrespectful and that he preferred to stay on the
street.
Community First helped him create a résumé and secure an
interview to work as a street cleaner in Times Square.
“Everything is working out just right,” he said. “I needed
this.”
Some business leaders are skeptical. “I don’t think
persuasion is going to get people off the streets,” said Barbara Blair, the
president of the Garment District Alliance, which represents businesses and
property owners south of Times Square.
Ms. Blair, who has advocated removing homeless people from
Midtown hotels, said the city had “utterly failed in terms of providing
supportive housing for people who are very, very ill.” A middle ground should
be possible, she said.
“The city has to balance keeping the streets livable for the
rest of the population and at the same time removing these people from the
streets into a place that’s safe,” she said.
David Stayback, a construction
worker in Times Square who was homeless in the area for two years, said the
neighborhood had become an uneasy environment for him and his colleagues. “I’ve
had knives pulled on me,” he said.
“I was a formerly homeless ex-con on the streets selling
drugs,” he said. “When I talk to you like this, I’m not judging them.”
As recently as a year ago, after the Black Lives Matter
protests, the city moved to reduce officers’ interactions with homeless
people, disbanding
the Police Department’s Homeless Outreach Unit. It has
done an about-face in response to public outcry.
So the sweeps go on. At 14th Street and First Avenue in the
East Village, a choreographed routine has developed.
One recent morning, street vendors set up tables a
respectful distance from a sign announcing the day’s cleanup.
The city crew arrived. A sanitation supervisor took a photo
of the sign that showed the lack of clutter around it. “I’ve just got to show
my boss that I came and I did my job,” he said.
As officers stood guard, an outreach worker tried to convince
a woman named Yolanda Evans to go to a group shelter. Ms. Evans said her many
health problems made the risk unacceptable during an epidemic.
“How am I going to stay in a room with eight to 10 people?”
she asked.
One homeless book vendor, Michael Jones, said the city crews
had served a purpose.
“You had people building shanty towns near the scaffolding
and terrorizing people,” he said. “At the end of the day, people were messing
up a good hustle.”
Under the High Line, Melvin Douglas is tiring of playing cat
and mouse. A week after his belongings were thrown out two days in a row, he
stashed them neatly behind a pole, left briefly and returned to find them gone
yet again.
“I don’t even have a clean change of underwear right now,”
he said as he sat dejectedly beneath a sign announcing that the crew would
return the next day.
Mr. Douglas said he might set up camp elsewhere in the city.
He said he had been where he was, thinking he was not
bothering anyone, for close to three years.
“This is my spot,” he said.
In a related incident, a Hawaii homeless man was locked up
in a mental institution for three years before the courts let him go.
ATTACHMENT
EIGHT – From Vox 8/1/21
FEDERAL EVICTION PROTECTIONS HAVE ENDED, LEAVING RENTERS SCRAMBLING
Only $3 billion
of a $45 billion relief package has been distributed to renters.
By Maryam Gamar Aug 1, 2021, 5:00pm EDT
It’s
August 1, and rent is due. That’s a big change for many Americans who had been
unable to pay rent but were protected from eviction by a federal moratorium.
Now, those protections are gone.
Due to
widespread job loss and the health risks of the Covid-19 pandemic, many renters
in the US faced difficulty making their rent payments every month when the
pandemic began in early 2020, and the federal government stepped in to prevent
people from getting evicted in the midst of it. As part of this
response, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention instituted a
moratorium in September 2020 that prevented landlords from evicting their tenants
regardless of whether they could pay their monthly rent in full or at all.
Last month
the moratorium was already on borrowed time, as the Supreme Court had warned
that it would not extend the renter protection past the end of July. Several justices including
Justice Brett Kavanaugh supported this. “In my view, clear and specific
congressional authorization (via new legislation) would be necessary for the
CDC to extend the moratorium past July 31,” wrote Kavanaugh.
The Biden
administration did challenge the Supreme Court decision on Thursday, two days
before the program was set to expire, by formally asking Congress to pass an
extension. But Congress would have had to pass new legislation to create an
extension, and did not do so in time before leaving for an August recess, so the moratorium has
officially expired.
No more eviction protection means
paying late rent, money renters don’t have.
This
changes a lot for renters who now have to reckon with their landlords, some of
whom have not received regular rent for almost a year. Renters are now required to pay any missed payments,
and in some states the landlord is owed late fees for any late payment since
the moratorium was enacted. Utilities are a bit of a gray area, but generally
if the landlord is responsible for paying for a certain utility, in most
cases they are not permitted to turn it off.
Rep. Cori
Bush (D-MO) was at the forefront of the fight for a further moratorium
extension. As a formerly homeless person who has also faced eviction in the
past, she has been vocal about the need to extend the moratorium, and slept on
the US Capitol steps on Friday night in protest. “I am dirty, sticky, sweaty. I
still have on what I had on last night. This is how people will have to live if
we don’t do something … they deserve human dignity and deserve for people that
represent them to show up, do the work, to make sure basic needs are met
today,” she told CNN’s Jessica Dean on Saturday.
According
to a study by the Aspen Institute and the Covid-19
Eviction Defense Project published in August of last year, nearly 40 million
Americans were then at risk of eviction. People of color were, and still
remain, disproportionately at risk as they are twice as likely to be renters. And the pressures
that Covid-19 added just worsened the statistics. A June report by
City Life/Vida Urbana and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology found that
in the first month of Massachusetts’s state of emergency during the pandemic,
78 percent of eviction filings in Boston were in communities of color.
People
with lower-income households are also more at risk, as they are less likely to
have savings to pay rent and more likely to have been employed in Covid-affected industries.
The moratorium aimed to help people like this who needed protection.
But
although politicians like Cori Bush are fighting to bring the moratorium back,
it was never a complete solution: Renters would eventually have to start paying
again whether their individual circumstances had changed or not, while
landlords were also struggling to make ends meet without rental income.
In an
attempt to remedy this, Congress allocated $25 billion in rental
assistance in December, and in March, another $21.5 billion was added. This was
a welcome relief to tenants and landlords alike, but the problem was in getting
the money to the people who needed it, quickly. Confusion at the federal level
about how to distribute that amount of money, and which of numerous programs
would handle distribution, has also slowed getting the aid out. As Vox’s
Jerusalem Demsas has reported, many renters in need
of aid simply did not know that they were eligible for rent relief, and if they
did, some were unable to provide the necessary paperwork because
of their turbulent living circumstances, lack of formal documentation of their
work, or nontraditional rental agreements.
Renters were unsure if rent
relief money would get to them in time
While more than $1.5 billion was delivered to eligible
applicants in the month of June, which exceeded the amount provided in all
three previous reporting periods combined, only $3 billion of the total $45 billion allocated has
been distributed, according to the US Treasury. Now that the federal moratorium
has expired, at least four states — Massachusetts, Nevada, New York, and Oregon
— have temporarily continued the ban on evictions against those with
a pending rental assistance application. These state decisions will give
renters time to receive their rent relief money when they might otherwise face
eviction immediately. But renters in states that are following the expired
federal moratorium face large sums of back rent, and if they are unable to pay,
possible eviction.
“There’s a
lot of cases where tenants are getting evicted that have already been approved
for rental assistance,” K’Lisha Rutledge, an attorney
with Legal Aid of NorthWest Texas, told the Texas Tribune. “And their landlord knows that
they’ve been approved, and they’re just waiting on the check.”
It might
be easy to see landlords as the villains in this situation, but tenants aren’t
the only ones struggling. Forty-one percent of all rental housing units in
the US, and most of the affordable housing options, are owned by individuals,
or “mom-and-pop” landlords, and the rent they receive from their tenants is
often a large part of their own income. This means that the moratorium
alleviated pressure from tenants by creating more pressure on landlords who
still need to pay their own bills.
As
Vox’s Jerusalem Demsas wrote:
“Losing more of
America’s already dwindling affordable housing stock is a looming emergency
that could be exacerbated if small landlords are required to act as the social
welfare state without any financial assistance.”
The end of
the moratorium potentially means money in landlords’ pockets, but
there are still roadblocks. California is allowing landlords to get paid what
they are owed from previous months without rent only if they waive 20 percent of the back rent. And some landlords have taken such a hit that they will be
forced to sell their property, eliminating the opportunity to continue renting
as a future source of income.
With over 50 percent of the US population vaccinated,
it may seem that now is an appropriate time to end the benefits of the
moratorium. But Americans who took a financial hit during the peak of Covid-19
or who lost their job may still need support. The rise of the Covid-19 delta
variant is also a concern, as research has shown that evictions lead to a higher
likelihood of Covid-19 infection and death.
Concerns
about the delta variant were also the main reason for the Biden
administration’s push for a moratorium extension. “Given the recent spread of
the Delta variant, including among those Americans both most likely to face
evictions and lacking vaccinations, President Biden would have strongly
supported a decision by the CDC to further extend this eviction moratorium to
protect renters at this moment of heightened vulnerability,” the White House said in a statement.
Based on the
Supreme Court decision, and absent action from the Biden administration and
Congress, this support is not enough. With over $40 billion in rental relief
left undistributed, and a threat to public health still looming, renters are in
danger once again.
ATTACHMENT NINE – From NOLO
STATE EVICTION PROTECTION
The chart below
attempts to capture the latest information on coronavirus-related tenant
protections by state (and county and major cities, if applicable). Please note that
this information is changing hourly, and the chart might not reflect all
current protections. For the best information about the status of evictions
where you live, check your state's judicial system or governor's website. You
can also contact a legal aid organization
in your area.
In the chart, click on
the state's name to be directed to its official COVID-19 website.
State |
County or City |
Hold On Evictions |
Hold on Utility Shutoffs |
Other Tenant Protections/Notes |
No |
No |
-Alabama's emergency rental assistance program. -Visit ALtogether to
find resources for assistance in Alabama. -Alabama's Coronavirus Relief Fund. -Public Service Commission states that
it is confident no customers will experience interruption during crisis, and
that after crisis period utilities will help with past-due accounts. However,
the decision is left to individual utility providers. |
||
No |
No |
-See the
Regulatory Commission of Alaska's COVID-19 utility information page. -Information for renters about 2021 rent relief programs. |
||
No |
No |
-Arizona Corporation
Commission's ban on utility disconnects has ended, but many providers are
extending the hold on disconnects and are offering assistance to customers.
Check with your provider. -Resources for
individuals in Arizona. -Arizona utility assistance programs. |
||
No |
No |
|||
Yes:
through 9/30/2021 |
Yes:
through 9/30/2021 |
-The governor has announced an extension of the eviction ban
through September 30, 2021. -Also see California Eviction
Moratorium (Bans) and Tenant Protections for the
status of bans in various California cities and counties. -Utility shutoff moratorium for nonpayment until at least
September 30, 2021 for most utilities. See the CPUC's website on
consumer protections during the COVID-19 outbreak for
details. |
||
No |
No |
-By order of the governor, landlords must
give tenants who have submitted an application for rental assistance 30 days'
notice of nonpayment of rent before they can file an eviction suit. -See Colorado statewide utility tracker for
information about whether your utility provider has put a moratorium on
shutoffs during the crisis. You can also get current information about
utility assistance programs on the PUC's website. -Check your court's website to see
status. -Colorado's Emergency Housing
Assistance Program (EHAP). |
||
No |
No |
-Governor has ordered new steps landlords must take before
delivering a notice to quit for nonpayment of rent, as
well as other tenant protections (extended through September 30, 2021). -Connecticut's UniteCT (emergency rental
assistance program). |
||
No |
No |
-Delaware Housing Assistance Program -By order of governor, and until the end
of the public health emergency, landlords could file eviction lawsuits, but
courts were required to stay any proceedings. Order was in place until the
end of the state of emergency, which ended July 13, 2021. |
||
Yes: see notes |
Yes |
-The mayor has signed an act phasing out the eviction and utility shutoff
moratoriums. More updates once mayor's office has posted
the final signed version. -D.C.'s STAY program (rent and utility
assistance). |
||
No |
No |
-Florida Housing's
COVID-19 Information and Resources. |
||
No |
No |
-Georgia Rental
Assistance Program. -Courts have discretion as
to whether eviction hearings can proceed; check individual Georgia courts'
status here. -Georgia utility assistance programs. |
||
Yes:
through 8/6/2021 |
No |
-By order of governor, evictions for
nonpayment of rent suspended through August 6, 2021. Governor has
stated that the eviction ban will not be renewed after
August 6, 2021. -Resources for emergency rental assistance in Hawaii. |
||
No |
No |
-Idaho emergency rental assistance. -Landlords and tenants in
Ada County who are involved in an eviction for nonpayment of rent will
be invited to negotiate an agreement through an online
portal. -For financial and other
assistance, the Idaho Public Utilities Commission has a
county-specific resource guide. |
||
See notes |
No |
-By order of governor, as of August 1,
2021, landlords can file eviction lawsuits for nonpayment of rent. Law
enforcement can't carry out evictions, though, until August 21, 2021. (Also
see Executive Orders 2021-13 and 2021-14 for details.) -Tenants and landlords
might be able to get assistance through the Illinois Rental Payment Program (ILRPP). |
||
No |
No |
|||
No |
No |
-Iowa Rent and Utility Assistance Progam -Rent and utility
assistance for residents of Polk
County and the City of Des Moines |
||
No |
No |
|||
No |
No |
-Kentucky's Healthy at Home Eviction Relief Fund. -Many utilities have
voluntarily agreed to not shutoff for nonpayment. Please contact your utility
provider for options. |
||
No |
No |
-Louisiana's Emergency Rental Assistance Program -For information on
utilities, visit the Louisiana Public Service Commission's website. -Louisiana Law Help is
regularly updating its website with COVID-19 information for Louisiana residents. |
||
No |
No |
-Maine's Emergency Rent Relief Program. |
||
Yes: through 8/15/2021 |
No |
-By governor's order, no evictions
statewide during emergency. Emergency declaration lifted effective July 1,
2021, but there is a 45-day grace period (until August
15, 2021) during which the eviction ban remains in place. See the Maryland Attorney General's consumer alert for
more information. -Maryland's Emergency Rental Assistance Program |
||
No |
No |
-Massachusetts state resources for renters. -For utility information,
see the DPU list of utility assistance
resources. |
||
No |
No |
-Michigan's COVID Emergency Rental Assistance (CERA). |
||
Yes: See
notes |
Maybe (see
notes) |
-MN legislature has passed
an "eviction off ramp" law. As of August 13, 2021, landlords can
terminate the lease of renters who are behind in rent and are not eligible
for a COVID-19 emergency assistance plan. As of September 12, 2021, landlords
can file evictions. For detailed information visit Minnesota Housing's RentHelpMN
website (see particularly it's FAQs and timeline for
off ramp). -Information about utility assistance. |
||
No |
No |
|||
No |
No |
|||
No |
No |
-Renters can seek relief
from the Montana Emergency Rental Assistance program. -Visit the Montana Public
Service Commission's website to locate your utility
service provider's website and find out about status. |
||
No |
No |
-Nebraska emergency rental assistance program. -More information and resources
available from Nebraska Legal Aid. |
||
No |
No |
|||
No |
No |
|||
Yes: until
end of emergency +2 months |
No |
-Governor's order prohibits
removal of tenants from residential properties, and postpones enforcement of
all judgments for possessions, warrants of removal, and writs of possession.
See New Jersey Eviction
Moratorium Information + Question Form for more
information. -New Jersey emergency rental assistance program. -See NJ's Board of Public Utilities FAQs on End of Shutoff
Moratorium and Grace Period -New Jersey utility assistance
programs. |
||
Yes |
No |
-See New Mexico's website
on the utilities' response to COVID-19. -NM courts have placed a
temporary moratorium on eviction. You must provide the court with evidence of
current inability to pay rent at your hearing on the eviction petition.
Eviction hearings will be held by video or phone, unless parties file a
motion for in-person hearing. The NM Supreme Court has a FAQ page for more
information. Moratorium in place until end of emergency. -New Mexico Emergency
Rental Assistance Program -Many utilities have
suspended shutoffs. Check with your provider for
information. |
||
Yes: through 8/31/2021 |
Yes |
-The state
legislature's COVID-19 Emergency Eviction and Foreclosure Prevention
Act of 2020 was extended through August 31, 2021. It
prohibits evictions and puts various tenant protections in place. -New York emergency rental assistance program. -Apply for New York Heating and Cooling Assistance
(HEAP) program here. |
||
-Ohio Home Relief Grant (for
landlords and tenants). -Ohio
Public Utilities Commission's information on utility plans. |
||||
-Pennsylvania emergency rental assistance. -Pennsylvania Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program
(LIHEAP) |
||||
-South Carolina SCStay program (COVID-19
housing assistance) |
||||
-South Dakota CARES Housing Assistance Program -Check South Dakota PUC website for
resources related to utilities. |
||||
-Tennessee
Housing Development's list of energy assistance programs for renters. -Tennessee Office of the Courts' list of eviction resources. |
||||
-See Vermont Legal Aid's website for
details about evictions in Vermont. |
||||
See notes re: eviction moratorium
"bridge" through 9/30/2021 |
-Utility shutoff moratorium extended through September 30, 2021. -Washington Utilities and Transportation Commission's information on COVID-19 utility assistance. |
|||
-Wisconsin Rental Assistance Program. |
||||
ATTACHMENT TEN - From the Wall Street Journal
OPINION: DELTA VARIANT PITCHES COVID INTO CONFUSION
By The Wall Street Journal Editorial Board Updated Aug. 2,
2021 1:18 pm ET
The eviction moratorium was perhaps
justifiable amid the early lockdowns that threw millions out of work, but it’s
now a cautionary tale of how bad policies distort behavior and are difficult to
end. The
original Cares Act moratorium that only applied to federally subsidized housing
expired last July, but the Trump Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
imposed its version in September. The moratorium applied to all rental housing
and tenants who earned less than $99,000 ($198,000 for couples) who claimed
they lost income because of the pandemic. Landlords who evicted non-paying
tenants could go to jail.
ATTACHMENT ELEVEN – From “EVICT THEM for ME!”
·
HOME